How do you rate a hotel is the question? Stars are fa airly meaningless guide. To my wife and I the facilities are important, but if something is not correct then the attitude of the staff is critical. Location and ambiance is also a highly rated factor. The Calamidoro has all these factors. It is favorably situated 6km North of main Livorno-Pisa-Florence Autostrada (non-toll) just 25km from Central Pisa and 60km from Florence. Access to the Tuscan hills, villages and countryside is easy.
We arrived on a very hot (34°C) July afternoon and checked in. The reception is in a separate complex to the main hotel complex. I would not advise staying in a standard room in the reception complex as it can be noisy, (I suspect) from the disco, main road and poolside activities. The reception staff were smiling, happy and very helpful. Their English was good-excellent. We were escorted to the main hotel complex which is located through an electronic set of gates opened with your room keycard. The room we booked was a "duplex" with the bed on a second floor mezzanine deck. The lounge and bathroom were located on the lower floor. Some of the duplex' s are located on the ground floor of each block and others are enterd on the second floor of the block. Some have baths with shower whilst others have only showers.
The room we had was extremely hot and try as we could we could not get the a/c to work effectively, so back to reception who checked and found that the central a/c unit was tripping out frequently. They offered us another room for the night in an adjacent block with a different a/c unit while the electricians attempted to trace and rectify the fault so we could move back for the remaining 4 nights of our stay. Unfortunately the next day they had not rectified the problem so we permanently moved to the alternative room, which was not the duplex style accommodation as none were available for all our stay.
The "American" bar is in the central block and provides a venue for a full cold buffet-style breakfast with a variety of cold meats, chesses, fruit, cereal and pastries. The internet pc is also there with a printer attached, which is useful for attraction and map printing and online airline check-in (no MS Word or Excel installed). The bar is manned by Lorenzo and Carlo, both fluent English-speakers and a fountain of local knowledge. Bar prices are a bit high, 7 euros for a beer, but if you are staying in 4-star hotel this is not unusual. The pool is nice but with only 14 stretcher sun beds it is under-catered, especially if certain nationalities "pre-book" the beds with their towels and books early in the morning!
Restaurants: There is an excellent restaurant, opens at 8pm, 7 days per week and meals are chargeable to the room, The restaurant is located around the pool next to reception. Prices are not too inflated and compared with other good-quality (not pavement) restaurants. There are menus are available in English, and other languages, and the head waiter speaks good English. The alternative pizzeria is adequate but not outstanding. Also on the complex, but not part of the hotel is the Wine Shop restaurant which serves a general menu of meat, fish, pasta and pizzas. Did not eat there so cannot comment. The Music Bar between the shops sells beer, wine and spirits at lower than hotel prices and from 6pm it serves a whole range of complimentary snacks, breads, pickles, dips etc. - Recommended!!. Carlo directed us, and booked for us, another restaurant in a nearby village, Restaurant delle Mimosa (left out of hotel car park, into Bentinia, right at end of market square, right at traffic lights, follow road as it bears left, up a hill 2-3km, and watch for Ice creanm Cone sign on the right, turn into street after cone sign and to the bottom of the street, park and walk into restaurant) booking is necessary as it is very popular with local residents. The ambiance is great, food and wine is good, service is excellent, prices good (but not cheap - 66euro for 2 courses and wine for 2 people). The menus are only in Italian and only one or two waiters speak a little English, but well worth a visit.
There is archery and a golf driving range onsite with a 1-hole practice tee.
Would we stay ther again? If we go to that region again-definitely.
Although there is a bus service to the station at Pontedera I consider your own transport to be a necessity.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC