We visited Mains of Taymouth on the back of a recommendation and reviews on TripAdvisor - I can see why people enjoyed it so much but we found our stay thoroughly disappointing. Many of the ideas are great but the execution is a bit sloppy and all the finishing touches that should have made it a great holiday left us wanting more. We stayed in the Bell Tower and far too many things ruined what could have been an enjoyable week.
The positives first:
The location is very nice - plenty of good views around the area.
The cottages are generally well equipped and offer a good degree of luxury.
The bathroom was excellent - big shower, big bath and a sauna - all well looked after.
Food at the nearby Courtyard restaurant was good.
Overall, nice cottages in a nice location... BUT...
The first night we stayed there the heating broke due to a known fault that they hadn't yet fixed and hadn't warned us about so we woke up in the morning shivering in a very cold cottage.
The log fire they have in the kitchen/living area should have been great but with no matches to be found and an all electric hob/oven we had to get some matches before we could try it out and the only tool we had for tending the fire was a shovel - great for clearing out ash, not so good for moving hot logs.
Privacy is a bit of an issue - the curtains/blinds were very thin, some of them didn't even sit against the windows and left huge gaps down the side which made it very easy to see people wandering around outside and for them to see in. Privacy was particularly bad at the top of the stairs where two uncovered skylights in the angled roof meant people in the other cottages or walking around outside could see straight in to the cottage.
The television downstairs was stuck on the wall at a 90 degree angle to the sofa so you couldn't sit and watch anything. Meanwhile, the television in the bedroom was just plain dangerous. At 6'3", I was always going to struggle getting through the very low entrance into the bedroom - something my wife who is a foot shorter could only just do without ducking - but even once I was in, a TV has been stuck on the wall right above the entrance for you to whack your head on if you stand up to soon.
None of these would necessarily have ruined the week on their own but combined together with many other small things such as none of the clocks working (they all had dead batteries) and an incomplete welcome pack (which didn't contain the promised discount vouchers for the Courtyard) I left feeling let down and disappointed. It wasn't an uncomfortable week, but for the price we paid our expectations were much higher!
We stayed in a holiday home in the French Alps a couple of years ago for a quarter of the price and while the Bell Tower had many additional luxuries for us to enjoy, the poor attention to detail let it down and it wasn't even twice as good, let alone four times as good.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
1 December 2011
We have always experienced our best reviews from the Bell Tower and we are so disappointed that on this one occasion we have not managed to fulfil your expectations. Bell Tower is a 19th centuary house that has recently been renovated to a 5 star Visit Scotland standard with spa bathroom, sauna, roll top bath, under floor heating, four poster bed and is designed for the discerning couple loking for that special, luxurious retreat. The Bell Tower is very quaint and still has many of it's original features - stone archway to the bedroom (yes, us tall people scuff our heads until we get used to it!), log fire and all built in the originial Bell Tower of the original Taymouth Castle Home Farm. It is a unique A Listed building in a lovely location - a perfect escape for a couple looking for a private time.
Of course, we apologise for the minor day to day problems that were fixed immediately.
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC