If you don't get much feedback in the forum (kind of difficult to find people who could compare multiple hotels if they haven't stayed in more than one in this list...) you can do what a normal anal-retentive type would do and start a spreadsheet.
List the hotel, the rate (* by Levant rate for incl breakfast), and add columns for things like:
- quiet / noise
- room amenities
- desk / service
- condition of the rooms
- easy to travel from
- easy to find nearby cafes, grocer, baker, whatever
Next, troll the TA review for each hotel and try to flag the above columns based on comments.
Then, at the end, you may have a summary comparison.
Slight less time-consuming: look them up on a map and see if any are on main arteries - these might be noisy if you are traveling when you need to open windows for cool air. (you won't need a/c in October, but you might sometimes want to circulate some air).
My memory thinks your selections are probably located in a fairly tight circle on the map, so overall location would be about equal.
While you are studying the locations on the map, be sure to note which are closest to TWO metro stops on different lines, if any - - that is a plus for convenience.