The burgers are not very special but the bread is great and the french fries are great. The diner itself is small and nice. Service good and fast.

If it wasn't for the service, we probably would have left when the food came. Not impressed with the thick hamburger buns, would have liked a little more meat on the burger.

we spent two weeks in kihei in april and one day we had a craving for an old fashioned burger.. a couple of nights previously we had enjoyed a great supper over at coconuts cafe where this neat restaurant is located next too and when that burger fix needed fixing we popped in... we can tell you the burger was... More

My husband and I found Peggy Sue's in Kihei just a delightful throw back to the 50's. jukeboxes on every table were you could select your favourite songs. I played the Hawaii 5.0. Theme quite a bit. Waitresses dressed the part, service was great and the food was good. We went twice and met other Canadians there too. A great... More

We re-visited Peggy Sue's after loving it 8 years ago on vacation. We were all disappointed. The hamburger was dry and flavorless. Even the French fries weren't good. I don't know what happened, but it was not the Peggy Sue's we used to love. On a positive note, the milk shake was still good!

Whenever I get tired of the fancy shmancy eateries that abound on this island with their overpriced food and drinks I take my self down to Peggy Sues for and overpriced cheeseburger. (Let's face it folks, everything on this island is overpriced and you can't find a burger anywhere for less than $10 bucks) I see some reviewers found Peggy... More

Service was good & atmosphere was fun - how can it not be when it's mirrored after an old time diner! We all ordered burgers and they were very sizeable and tasty. Half of the group ordered milkshakes and shared with the rest of us in the group and they were very good. Kids loved that they could pick their... More

I wish I had read the reviews before going as I usually do but went to Peggy Sue's on the way home from a day at the beach. Horrible service to start with. We wanted onion rings and were told they had 'run out'! That should have been a sign to leave as that would indicate they purchase frozen ones.... More

We checked Peggy Sue's out on trip advisor like many of the restaurants we tried while in Maui. The reviews were very positive so we decided to give it a try. The burgers were very dry and very bland. also they had "run out of onion rings" I think I'm stating the obvious but are burgers not what they are... More