I think my original review came off as snotty, so I wanted to revise it. The food was good, just heavier than I was expecting. I would definitely come back here for a lighter lunch, and sit in the windowed front area for a change of view.

Mission Grille was our second choice but we are certainly glad our first choice was closed that weekend. Everything here was perfect. The restaurant itself is lovely and beautifully decorated especially during the holidays. Our server, (I wish I could remember her name because it was unique) was very friendly and attentive. She told us about the menu options and... More

Decided to eat here because this restaurant used to be a catholic church and was curious on what we would find. We ate lunch here because the dinner menu was a little more expensive than lunch. They had an excellent menu and it was hard to choose what to eat. The restaurant is very beautiful inside. Enjoyed our meal. Would... More

Nice crowd and the service is very good. I had the grilled salmon salad one day and one of the day's specials the next. The lobster bisque was very dissapointing but that was the only negative. Otherwise, a terrific place to meet friends and enjoy some good food and wine.

Nice atmosphere, a converted old church hence the name. Menu had beef, chicken, seafood, pasta, and salads. Had green Apple and goat cheese salad with dried cherries, loved it! Large choices a wines. Will be back again and again.

Located in a historic remodeled church this restaurant has a lovely atmosphere. The menu was extensive with interesting entree's. We all loved our selections- I am sure there is nothing on the menu that would disappoint the palate. For fine dining, you will find no better in Door county.

I had the Filet Mignon and it was very tender and juicy. I want one right not! The atmosphere was great and the wait staff were perfect. This is a must for dinner when visiting Sister Bay.

Wonderful food, fabulous atmosphere. Every dish here is prepared great - they make a fabulous martini, and the wine selection is awesome. We visit Mission Grille on every trip to Door County.

We make sure to eat at the Mission Grill at least once every trip to Door County. I have never had anything other than the Filet, but it is amazing. Also, love the blue cheese stuffed potato pancakes. Ambiance & staff are awesome. Definitely recommend stopping here for supper or even just for drinks at the bar.