My husband and I chose this restaurant because we wanted to go someplace very special to celebrate a milestone. I read the reviews before we went so I was really excited about the steak that other reviews raved about. Our server was well informed and really was quite talented at describing the dishes and doing his job to "sell" the... More

Stopped for dinner as I was in town on business in Sheboygan. I dined here many years ago and remembered it is a great restaurant. I was not disappointed. The atmosphere, the service, and the food is superb. Hard to believe that you can find such a great restaurant in a small city like Sheboygan Wisconsin. Had a wonderful salad... More

The food was interesting and good with an adequate wine list. Service was pleasant and an overall enjoyable experience. Worth the visit when in the area. More

A mixed review.... The food is excellent, but the portions are very small. I mean we spent over $150.00 there (including ONE drink for each of us) Just 2 people in our party. For pasta dinners?? Bring your wallet!! More

We went here after another place we wanted to go to was booked for the night. Stefano was packed, too, but we were able to sit at the corner of the bar. I guess this place is a staple in Sheboygan, and we understand why. The bruschetta was fantastic. We also sampled the catch of the day and the veal... More

Just like Il Ritrovo, this place is extraordinary. My wife and I eat here almost as much as we do at Il Ritrovo. The last time we were here was the Saturday before Easter. It wasn’t as good as other times here but if you eat at the same places long enough, eventually there will be something to criticize. The... More

OH. MY. GOODNESS. I consider myself to be an Italian food snob. I lived in Italy for a half a year, I have amazing family cooks to look up to and boy was a I happy camper at Trattoria Stefano. Ambiance: brighter than most fine dining establishments. Wood table and chairs with exposed cream city brick walls. Nice fixtures and... More

I loved the food and a good place for a date night. More

Fresh incredients imaginatively prepared. Superb service by knowledgeable servers. Warm welcome by hosts. Comfortable, pleasant, unpretentious surroundings. A favorite place for special celebrations, especially. More