Walking in it has a great atmosphere and the staff is friendly, but that is only 1/4 of the experience, I personally thought the food was quite greasy and with only having 15 or so items on the menu it should be better. That being said i felt my options were limited.

We love this authentic pizza place, but wish it had better hours. Call first!

The food here is outstanding! 100% authentic and the portions are more than generous. The only down falls I had about this restaurant was that it is pretty small. Also it took a while for us to get our food, but thats only because the owner is the only one in the kitchen.

My family and I went here after spending the day at Road America. The waitress was very pleasant. We ordered the Chicago style pizza and it was very good. The atmosphere was relaxing which we needed after being outdoors all day.

This is a small restaurant - the size of a small cafe with about 6 or 7 tables. They take reservations, which we have on the few occasions we've gone. No off-street parking. I've had the manicotti there twice. Not swimming in sauce, perfectly done noodles - not too firm. Nice plating and super hot and fresh. BEST I've had... More

Amazingly good italian - eat here and you won't regret it. Not cheap, but a great value given the quality. Very small, so service can suffer when busy, but worth the wait.

My husband & 2 kids stopped at Bellafini's on a Friday night on our way to Oshkosh. I selected this place based on TripAdvisor reviews. The food was delicious. The atmosphere was magical, especially as it started to snow while we were eating. This is a small place that is easy to miss. My husband had the Shrimp Diablo. I... More

Growing up with a Sicilian mother, I have learned to cook quite a bit of wondeful and authentic italian and sicilian meals. I never dreamed of finding somewhere as similar to my mothers cooking, or even my own, when I moved to wisconsin. Luckily, I found Bellafinis, such a lovely atmosphere, very quaint with great service. It is to my... More

Who would have thought? After some disappointing adventures in our home town we'd find this gem in Fond du Lac. BELLAFINI's scores! Tucked away from the center of town but not too far south on Main (at 14th) is a real charmer. Start with a couple glasses of Chianti, an order of bruschetta and the house salad (dressing to die... More