My husband and I ordered the PMS (medium) pizza and it was delicious! We ordered it to go to bring back to our hotel. Great size and really tasty! All they people that worked there greeted us and were nice. I highly recommend and we'll be back!

We tried this place one evening because of the Trip Advisor reviews. You have to place your order up at the counter and then take a seat and they bring you your food. They bring it directly to your table when it is ready but the meals come out at different times. We were half way finished with our pizza... More

As winter residents we searched a long time to find quality thin crust pizza!! Amazing fresh ingredients all the locals know the place, fun bar, good prices no delivery but worth going to pickup!!!

Exceptional Customer Service, Fun atmosphere, Excellent Food. Enough Said!!!!!!!!! If your not stopping at this place you missing out

The title says it all...this pizza is by far the best on the island!! Coming from a gal that was raised in the NY/NJ area this should speak volumes! My only complaint would be it was very toasty in the dining room, maybe the a/c was broken when we went the other night so we will surely be back very... More

Last night I had a mushroom and spinach calzone that was the best I have ever had! The ingredients were fresh and great quality. My husband had a meatball sub that he also loved. Now all calzones that I eat will be compared to this one! This restaurant is small but was able to accommodate the large group that came... More

We ate at Fat Baby's today and had a great pizza! We ordered the Py's pie and thought we would have a few slices leftover. It was so good we ate the whole thing-along with our greek salad. We will definitely go back when we come back to HHI. We will be recommending Fat Baby's to our friends.

We stopped in today 3/29/2013 after reading the reviews. The service here makes the experience worth while. The staff was great and very polite with kids. The food is not the best I have ever had but it was good, just a little well done crust on the calzones and pizza. Will visit again on our next trip.

The pizza was great and the atmosphere was very cool, biker bar meets pizza place. Service was friendly and fast. We had the margherita pizza and the kids got a pepperoni, both were excellent. The fresh mozzarella on the margherita was delicious! They had a cool juke box that we picked several songs from and the 8 year-old loved the... More