We thought we would give it a try. We called in our order and arrived early and were greeted by the one Employee behind the counter (who was maybe 12) and told us about 10 more minutes. I believe his brother came back after a delivery. The pizza was finally ready and it tasted like a grocery store frozen pizza,... More

Very mediocre pizza. Tasted like they started with a frozen peperoni or cheese pizza base and added ingredients. I was very disappointed and it was definitely not worth the price,

I like this place. it's unadulterated food. i really enjoyed the philly cheese steak i had and the pizza as well. it's the perfect place to grab a quick bite.

I absolutely fell in love with their chicken Philly, it was one of the best i have ever eaten. its a small place and if you dont pay attention you could easily drive past it. but everyone that worked their was friendly and nice. I would def recommend it!

Visited this nice private owned pizza shack in mid June, and it was delightful! The owners and workers are very nice and friendly! The pizza was wonderful and i cannot wait to head back this summer! Highly Recommended when in town!

You can buy a better frozen pie at the grocery store & microwave it yourself. The worst pizza we ever had. Overpriced garbage!!!!

We just spent two weeks in Garden City and visited Garden City Pizza several times (since the snack bar at our condo building right next door was rarely open). My 17 year old became addicted to the chicken wings, he said they were the best he has ever had. I loved the garlic bread (which was pizza dough baked with... More

Was very happy with the pizza. Delivery guy was a little unfamiliar with the area and it took him awhile to find our condo located wihin walking distance. Pizza was VERY good!

The food was of great quality and the service was very good. Our pizza was made with a good sauce and the toppings were fresh and plenty. We also recommend the spicy wings. It was very nice that the place was open really late.