Arguably best Italian in area. Try the veal park. Not cheap but lots and very good. Owner bartender on the grumpy side but that's ok. Def a must see place on 'other side of tracks'. More

The garlic bread/pizza is unbelievable. We've been ordering that for decades and have never found any other restaurant that can come close. Their spaghetti and other dishes are wonderful, and the tossed salads are also very good. The staff is great and the atmosphere very comfortable. We always recerve a booth in the bar area because we enjoy the atmosphere. More

For this area it's good. Garlic pizza tasty and price is reasonable. I was surprise my salad I asked for blue cheese dressing and it was just blue cheese with a vinegar dressing. More

I used to live in Horseheads, NY and visited Mangiardo's as often as possible. Now I live in the Greenville/Spartanburg, SC area and I can honestly say I have yet to find a place that has food that good. I miss the hometown atmosphere and the garlic pizza, one of a kind. And they make a darn good Bloody Mary!!!... More

It was so cold, even waitress looked frozen. Food was good but the bartender was lethargic and bored. Menu selections were antique. More

Mangi's has been a family favorite or as long as I can remember. As an owner of my own private company I often host out of town reps. I usually make it a point to take my guests out for dinner one night during their stay. Last night my guests and I went to Mangilardos. It was nothing short of... More

The sausage with peppers, onions and mushrooms was great! Also the garlic bread was fabulous! We stop each time we are in sayre. The outside should not discourge More

The best pizza. Made fresh and great ingredients. The pasta is great too. More

I recently dined at Mangialardo's with several members of my family (16 in all). You would think a small local operation like this would welcome our business. Think again. The owner, Fran Smith, is miserable and rude and totally sets the tone for the rest of the staff. The waitresses are horrible.....slow with absolutely no customer service skills. I agree... More