We have eaten here several times. It is usually ok, but you never know. The service and food quality are not consistent. They do most always bring bread, oil, and garlic knots out to the table. Pizza is usually good - but not always. Entrees are okay, the sauce is great real Italian style and tasty, but food maybe a... More

I heard good things about this place so I tried it. WORST mistake in my dining life! Fish fry came with one and a half pieces of fish like Long John Silvers (frozen and battered, just drop in fryer). One order was broiled (not a fish FRY!) and one tablespoon of coleslaw. Come on people, really now! I did get... More

The Friday night fish dinner was delicious and I am fussy about my fish. I ordered it fried and it filled the plate and was very very good! Choice of spaghetti or fries, a big tossed salad as well as coleslaw and dipping bread and garlic knots. A very delicious and satisfying dinner that I will certainly order again for... More

I have moved to Elmira about 4 years ago, and began to eat at Pietro's and Sons soon after. Being originally from Corning, I have frequented the other pizza places in Elmira and have hade enjoyable experiences. But the restaurant that I order my Pizza, wings, and Fine Italian food is at Pietro's. Pietro's has the best wings in the... More

We ordered dinner for take out tonight and we were very disappointed. Our Garlic Knots were cold. My wife ordered a Caesar Salad for $7.50 which consisted of Lettuce and nothing more! $7.50 for Lettuce! The overly tanned 50 year old working behind the counter was not friendly and told me the Garlic Knots were cold but said I could... More

Our party consisted of 3 adults for a late lunch/early dinner to celebrate a birthday by going out for some "good Italian" food. We were not dissapointed! The restaraunt dining area is average (at best) and the facility could use a little sprucing up/renovating but we werent there for the "Atmosphere" so we werent bothered by that! The restaurant was... More

I visited Pietro's last week - hadn't been there since the new owners took over. The food had always been fantastic when Pietro had it & there was a real Italian feel to the place. There was a table with 3 college students and no one else in the place. We sat & waited 15 minutes before deciding we'd waited... More

I have memories of that place, all good, none bad. More

Love the food, HATE THE SERVICE and the atmosphere isn't the warmest. More