Friendly staff and delicious food. Portions are huge and well worth it. Must have their homemade sausage. To. Die. For. Will definitely go back when we come to town again.
I decided to stay in Cooperstown on my way back from Central New York for Thanksgiving and wanted to find a nice place for dinner on Friday evening. Based on all of the positive Tripadvisor reviews, I decided to give Nicoletta's a try for the first time. We had a reservation for 6:30 and showed up at 6:20 and were... More
We had dinner here on the recommendation of our B&B innkeepers and enjoyed a very nice evening. Service was impeccable and the food was very tasty and nicely presented. Reservations are highly recommended, especially on the weekends. We were fortunate in that we walked in and were seated quickly. We would dine here again if we visit Cooperstown again in... More
This was an anniversary dinner for my husband and I. This was the perfect dining place! There was variety of food. So I had the lobster ravioli and my husband had the pasta and sausage. The wait staff was very attentive and the atmosphere was relaxing!
This was the first restaurant we ate at after arrival for a long weekend mini vaca. The service was friendly and efficient without being pushy and the atmosphere was cozy and warm. I had the Filet over linguine with a Gorgonzola sauce. It was cooked perfectly and I thoroughly enjoyed it. My wife and daughter had the veal and they... More
We ate here our first night in Cooperstown. The waitstaff was excellent. I am in a service industry and am of course more critical than others. Our sever took great care to make sure we were taken care of. We peer pressured my mother into dessert and the server handled that with a smile and gave us all silverware..Touche..I observed... More
My husband and I went here for our anniversary dinner while spending the weekend in Cooperstown. I had the crab soup special and the lobster ravioli. This was by far the best lobster ravioli I've ever had.....there were actual large chunks of lobster!! My husband had the Caesar salad that was not overly loaded with dressing and then the eggplant... More
This was my husband's dream trip, but this great family restaurant made it memorable for me as well. Veal was excellent as were the house wines. Service was personal and professional. Loved it.
I liked the environment. The lighting was right, the room is very open due to the high ceiling and it is not too, too big. The Chicken Parm was excellent and the pasta w/garlic and oil was super. I had ravioli was served on top of eggplant and it was good. The sauce is a little heavy for my liking... More
If you own or manage Nicoletta's Italian Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing