We stumbled in on Saturday night and got seated without reservations by the proprietress, who was warm, friendly, and inviting. The service was a tad slow, but the food was delicious and the atmosphere warm and inviting. We would definitely visit again. It was our favorite restaurant of the three we visited while we were in Whitefish.

Liked, uh.. Nothing. Seating was very uncomfortable. Service was slow. Music was an embarrassing effort by an old pianist and I assume his wife.. I felt bad for them. The food.. Seemed like it was from a can - ordered scallop carbonara - and it was all but inedible. Driven past this place for years because it always looked to... More

Loved the food (typhoon noodles first time, sliced steak second time), the warm atmosphere and the impeccable service. Well worth the price.

right across the street from a great home run motel, Good Medicine lodge---name says it all! Fit for foodies, and nice wine list.

Had NY dinner here. Appy's and Drinks were great (Vit. Spiders were a 10 out of 10). Main course was a different story. $32 for a Rib eye that was like Pan fried Pork Chop. Second visit here and still waiting to be wow'd.

Me and the wife stopped in at this place after a day at glacier park. It had been drizzeling most of the day and I was slightly bedraggled when we walked into this place on a Tuesday night. Jeans, Vodoo bowling shirt, boots and hat. I cut the counter culture figure. A request for a table was quickly met and... More

We (me, my wife, mother in-law, & father in-law) spent a week hanging out in Whitefish and GNP. We had our last meal at McGarry's and it was great ! We have been visiting this area for about 5-6 years and we always like to enjoy the local resturants. Our visit to McGarrys begain with walking into a perfectly planned... More

This place seemed to be a solid 4 or 5 star place by reviews, but we did not think it was more than average. I find the ambiance at The Lodge at Whitefish Lake a lot better. My friend did not mind her halibut, but nothing to rave about. My pasta was good, the sauce was fairly tasty, but the... More

I convinced everyone to eat dinner here based on the TA reviews, but I could tell there was some hesitation. By the end of dinner I was the hero for suggesting McGarrys.