Small intimate restaurant. Nice Selections. Modern Mayan. The drinks were a little too smokey. But the food was very good!
I had dinner there recently when Market Street had their OPEN HOUSE. We were lucky because we walked in around 4pm, and got the last table available. The service was excellent, and the food was delicious! I am a foodie, and highly recommend this restaurant. Wines excellent as well. Sometimes restaurants have poor selections. They have only a few to... More
We frequently each lunch here, and had dinner here recently for the first time. The place was packed, folks without reservations were being turned away or faced a very long wait. Reservations are a must, unless you tend to eat late. There were some empty tables available starting around 9:30 PM. The cuisine here is very different, and very interesting.... More
After reading all the reviews about this restaurant, I decided to go and give it a try. We ordered the shrimp and guacamole appetizer and were very disappointed. The shrimp was nothing special and the guacamole wasn't seasoned properly. They have a limited selection of entrees which is fine but they ran out of chicken on an early Saturday evening?!... More
We got lucky and happened to grab the last 2top table just before noon on a weekday. Many others were turned away who didn't think to make a reservation. Good food &!good service. Will return, but next time with a reservation ;)
After a morning concert, we arrived to a full house. After a short 15 minute wait we were seated at the window by a friendly hostess and immediately greeted by an equally hospitable waiter. All items on the bill are locally sourced, originally prepared, and attractively presented. My wife was more familiar with the place and new she would order... More
We arrived early for a later reservation( all that was available). They were able to seat us early. Staff kind and gracious! Food was outstanding! Bean cakes and empanadas ordered for appetizer was delicious! We loved their guacamole! For the main corse I had the gird it's. A smaller entree since we had the appetizers. My husband ordered the vegetarian... More
After walking around the fossil beds at The Falls of the Ohio, we pulled up trip advisor and ended up at this little jewel. The interior is very charming and the smell when you walk in the door is heavenly. We had the black beam cakes for starters and they were sooo good. I had an assortment of salutes for... More
Wish I could thank the woman who recommended it when we were shopping in Indiana. The food was even better than she said! The Avocado Appetiser was outstanding. The salad was fresh and tasty. I appreciate that they use fresh local foods. The Wait Staff was helpful and very welcoming. The main course was outstanding! It was delightful to see... More
First time dinner. Really enjoyed the guacamole appetizer. The portion was on the small side. Had the banana cream pudding. All I can say is, WOW! Next time I go I want to get the Vegetarian Burrito.
If you own or manage Mayan Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing