If you want to relax in an atmosphere that is casual but classy, this is the place to go. Music is eclectic and the food is great. Don't miss the desserts, they're worth the trip by themselves

Great place for a special weekend dinner. Call for reservations in the music room to see local talent while you eat. Great prime rib but the vegetarian dish of the day is often the best thing to get. Desserts are great but the bread pudding with the Captain Morgan's hard sauce is to die for. I like most sides but... More

I've never had less than wonderful food at the Cafe. The new building and grounds are really nice. I love the new Pizza and more menu. Have visited sometimes once a week.

I have eaten at Blue River Cafe many times over the past 15 years or so. We have had good experiences before when dining alone or with another couple. Today we went with our church group. Not such a great experience, although I must give credit to the food we received. Food was excellent. First when we arrived we were... More

I took the family and a friend to Milltown to try out the Blue River Cafe. We ordered the deep fried mushrooms as an app. and had the deep dish pizza which served 4 easily. I was impressed with both items. The live entertainment was also an added bonus. Most of all the price was very resonable. Will definitely be... More

The owner is the most pompus arrogant man I have ever met. He walked outside and slid 1 of the 2 heavy chairs at our table, yes our table , about 5 feet away, sat down, threw his head back, lit a cigarette and exhaled annoyingly like he was just exhausted. This was while there were 5 of us standing... More

The fish there are always good and not greasy, the coleslaw as great tasting and the atmosphere is so pleasant. The tea tasted very fresh and recently brewed. I visited on a Sunday when they were not busy.

I have been wanting to go to the Blue River Cafe in Milltown since it was rebuilt after their fire. We went last night with a large group of fun people. We were seated at 7:30. We had a wonderful young lady as our waitress. BUT....the music may have been ok but the room was too loud to hear it,... More

Great food every time and live local entertainment on weekends.