Ate there 3 times on my 4 day stay! Yes it was that good! The service was amazing and the staff remembered us and greeted me like we were family! Wonderful place to sit outside and people watch and enjoy drinks food and the weather... and for a more romantic setting there is the back deck with cozy seating a... More

Have to say extremely disappointing , the reviews must have been somewhere else , food over priced and pretentious , far better value to be had elsewhere in the village .

We ate here on our last night in Siesta Key. I wished at the time it was our first night! We sat outside, and we loved the ambience. There were two keys playing some music with a keyboard and guitar. Our server Stacy was on top of everything and made sure that our experience there was a pleasurable one. We... More

We ate outside and the ambiance was great. The food was excellent, we had the cottage burger and the truffle seafood pasta. We'll be back the next time we come!

It's always nice to visit an establishment that reeks of romance. We came in feeling festive, and enjoyed the character, charm, and vitality of the central space. After a wonderful and creatively prepared dinner we moved to the patio out back, where we were serenaded by a musician, playing sweet guitar music surrounded by swaying palms, while bathed in an... More

We've eaten at the Cottage both times we visited Siesta. A great deck and wonderful service. We love the menu.

We had the shrimp rolls, calamari and crab sliders - all very good. The staff is wonderful and the General Manager, Tim Wong works very hard. Very well run. Also the cabana area in the back is wonderful with live music playing all the time. Highly recommend.

Each intetesting and unusual dish that we had - ceviche, green pea risotto, bok choy and their distinctive Caesar salad - was well prepared with intense flavors that didn't overwhelm - will eagerly return - Stephan - our server - was courteous - attentive - just right. The back patio is quite informal - we sat on stools.

Just returned from a fantastic dinner at The Cottage in the Cabana area which was enjoyed by 6 gals! Waitress was knowledgeable and so friendly, making great recommendations. Entertainment was great. Favourite appetizers for presentation and flavour were Patio Salad, Crab Cakes and Short Ribs. All Main courses were excellent - especially Skirt Steak and Walu. We will definitely return... More