Oh, how I love my Goodfellas....awesome pizzas, salads, make your own dressing and wine! Can't forget the service, either. Great staff and the owner is fantastic! We feel like family there...Go now! More

We have been comming to Goodfella's for about a year and the food is fantastic. The people that work there are always very friendy and helpfull. It is a relaxed environment and Frank is always interested in the customers experience and how they are meeting everyone's expectations. Reminds me of the small family spots in Boston's North End. Can't beat... More

My wife and I have been frequenting this hidden gem for over a year now and continue to be "WOWed" with every visit. Owner, Frank and team are passionate and extremely knowledgeable about the menu and outstanding (locally crafted) wine selection. From the first time we walked in the door - we were made to feel like one of the... More

We are regulars now. The food, service and throw back atmosphere is hard to beat. More

Best gluten free pizza crust I ever had, plus homemade wine (yum). Super sausage parm. I love their sauce:) More

Best Pizza in Sarasota. The side salad was delicious too. Met the owner Frank, he was very informative and friendly. My husband and I will be back soon, there are so many wonderful dishes on the menu that we can't wait to try. Wine was great too. Try it you will like it. More

My girlfriend and I have lived in Sarasota for almost 3 years. We dine out frequently and this place is well worth it. I work at a popular restaurant on siesta key and I would recommend this cosy joint. The pizza is great and they make their own wine. Try it. Good service and friendly staff. Love the cheese burger... More

We are on vacation in Siesta Key for a couple weeks and we wanted to go out for some good pizza. We found Goodfella's in another review for another pizza restaurant and we decided to give it a try. We were very happy with the quality of the pizza - exceptional taste if you prefer some with a less commercial... More

Life long Sarasota resident who tries to explore a new restaurant each week so we decided to stop in for a pizza. All I can say is that it smelled good and the pizza at the next table looked good but we never got a server So we could not order our own to see. Staff was to busy at... More