We were driving on the end of the island by the lighthouse and saw Pinocchio's. The day before, we met a couple of folks while walking the Ding Darling trail, and they mentioned how good this place was. So we followed up on his suggestion. I got the Sanibel Krunch and watermelon ice cream on a waffle cone. I think... More

What a delicious variety of Italian Ice Creams. They even had several sugar free, fat free varieties. I had the Mocha Chocolate sugar free and it was wonderful. My family raved about the Wedding Cake with Almond and the Sanibel Crunch. Portions were huge... even the small was an ample size. Wish we would have found this place earlier in... More

Lines too long but we went late at nite to avoid crowds but even some nights lines would too long to wait. good ice cream tho

stopped here and tried the dirty sandollar...ok, sort of bland. not cheap. would most likely not go back. can buy ice cream (queenies) in market and cones and make out a lot better.

My wife went to Pinocchio's a few times during our week long visit. i usually save my calories for, uh, adult sodas so i don't usually go for sweets. i did give it a shot once and got one of the signature flavors available only at this shop, but stuck to a kiddie size. it was very, very good. four... More

Ice cream was great! Portions are huge. Don't be fooled with the cup size. Lay out of store is very small and crazy. Worth it.

My fiance and I were in the mood for some ice cream after being at the lighthouse so we rode our bikes there. She liked hers which was a coconut ice cream concoction but I was too busy enjoying my dirty sand dollar ice cream. It was awesome and I highly recommend it. Nice little spot definitely worth a visit.... More

Great Gelato and Ice Cream shop, lots of flavors to choose from and convenient location from anywhere on the east side of the island.

I had heard this was a must do for our Sanibel trip--well we tried to find it one night and by the time we did it was closed. We finally got to visit and sample the Sanibel Crunch Ice Cream--topped with an animal cracker. It was great