From the outside it looks like a quaint yellow home, and on the inside the atmosphere is warm, cozy, and friendly. Even though It was my first time there, I felt right at home as though I was a local among friends. It's the perfect spot for a family dinner or a romantic outing, the interior is gorgeous and the... More

I would like to thank Roberto's for making every visit a memorable one. The quality and quantity of the food never ceases to amaze us and the presentation is absolutely beautiful. I love the way that the food is made to order and never rushed and thrown together. It is always worth the wait. My family and friends love coming... More

Like the antique stores and old village surrounding the eatery, Roberto's Italian Eatery is worth finding and staying to eat! You have to look for it - it is a little yellow house in a complex of 3-4 antique shops. It is on the right side of the road (if you are heading south), just north of McIntosh, FL. The... More

This was our first time - what a pleasant surprise. It was the best Italian food we have had in the area. This is not fast food, everything is prepared to order. The food was excellent, the presentation was nice and the atmosphere was pleasant. It is worth the drive from Gainesville.

My wife and I were celebrating our anniversary weekend and we were told to try Robertos. At first glance it looks like nothing special. A simple conversion of a home into a restraunt. Heard good things but honestly was almost dissapointed when we first pulled up. I thought to myself "This is a great Italian restraunt?". The old addage Dont... More

I had to rate it this low because the owner needs to learn to manage this eatery in a more professional way. The service has much to be desired and he needs to be more prepared for lack of employees not showing up or quitting or hire better help. We keep going back only because the food is excellent but... More

Looking for a hearty, tasty meal in a friendly atmosphere? Check out Roberto's Italian Eatery near Micanopy & McIntosh, Florida. We stayed at the Herlong Mansion this weekend where breakfast is provided and got a great recommendation for dinner. My fish stew came on a platter with pasta and was enough to feed 2 hungry adults. The wait staff is... More

I was there in september, the place was very nice, with live guitar music. The owner and the staff were ok. They have to improve the cuisine quality (less american more italian cuisine) but the owner told me that they are doing it. In my opinion they should increase a little the price to achieve a better result. It was... More

Out in the middle of nowhere is one of the best Italian restaurants I've ever been to! HUGE portions, fantastic flavor, great presentation with the friendliest people you'd ever want to meet. Incredibly small, but BIG on charming. I'll make sure to go back as soon as I can get back up there. Thank you Roberto!