Very surprised to read the story about the rude service... I have been coming to costellos a few times a month for the past 8 years. One thing I love about the place is the service. The male manager I know has worked there for years and I recall an instance when I was not satisfied with my food he... More

We have been using Costello's for the last 3 years, the Pizza is always great, they seem to have had the same pizza chef for a long period of time and his food is always good. There used to be a girl working the bar named Jennifer, she was pleasant and always offered recognition to regular customers, she has been... More

The four of us had just finished walking a local art show near Abacoa Town Center and felt like having a light lunch. We had opted out of having the corn dogs, pretzels, and candied nuts at the show and were looking for something better. We came across Costello's and, with their outdoor seating on this fine, cool South Florida... More

Excellent Italian fare, good veal dishes and ask for the specials. Our waitresses have been fantastic, Melissa and Sylvia are the best!

Don't just eat pizza. The menu items are even better. Try the squid.

Enjoyed a nice birthday party there with friends. Service was good, quaint inside. Food tasty and everyone at the table enjoyed what they had. I had to send my dinner back because it of cold meatballs (the rest of it was steaming hot). Pizza maker in view but didn't notice him washing his hands in between various acitviites he was... More

Ate here with 5 friends last night and with 2 friends 2 weeks ago. Have been eating here on and off since they opened over 5 years ago. They have tables inside and outside under a large concrete overhang. We were seated outside as soon as we arrived and were greeted by an assisstant manager who checked our table for... More

Got a Travelzoo deal for a bottle of wine and pizza (3 topping) and salads. Salads and accompanying bread were very tasty and fresh. Pizza was very good also although not the New York style that I love. Service was great with a interesting waiter. Wine was mediocre but wet, contained alcohol and was basically free.

First thing that should have clued us in was EVERYONE was eating pizza! Sadly we ordered Chicken Parmigiana & Alla Bolognese w/ Sausage. The chicken was overcooked and tough, the Bolognese is basically crumbled meat on the pasta (I had to get a side of Marinara to make my own sauce) and the Sausage was very tough. (It was sliced... More