We ordered from the Pub menu as we were not extremely hungry. Our party ordered burgers, crab bisque, grits and shrimp, and house salads. We were informed that the chief would only prepare the burgers well done. Those orders were subsequently cancelled. The crab bisque ($8) was devoid of crab and would serve better as wallpaper paste. The cheese grits... More

Great service, beautiful hotel and dining room, good food. My husband and I left full and very satisfied with our experience. I have been told that Fri and Sat are the best nights to eat at the hotel but you should make reservations. More

Hotel is very old and quaint. Room was comfortable and the staff were very friendly. More

so sorry to hear some reviewers were not happy - we went for our third time in a few years and we eat out a lot and this is about the best food in north florida - our meal came out at the perfect timing and was about as good as food gets - shrimp & artichoke was spiced just... More

We had dinner last night. Our food took so long to arrive that we were about to leave. The food was good but not worth the wait. More

We have eaten here numerous times. The quality has declined drastically. The crab bisque has suffered the greatest loss, very little crab. The heart of palm salad was the only salvation... More

What a great place for fine dining, drinks and entertainment! This is the happening place in Cedar Key! If you like historic buildings Island Hotel was built in the 1880's with a wealth of history behind it. You are greeted by friendly staff on arrival. The aroma of delicious food gets you ready for some excellent food. I tried the... More

Had a excellent meal and service. Definately will go again More

We had a very nice meal here, good food although the fish was a bit heavy on the pecans... The waitress was very personable & attentive. Will go back. More