We read good reviews and thought we would check it out but were very disappointed. I asked for a white russian and it was like a milk shake with tons of ice cream - yuk! More

The Cutten Inn is my favorite restaurant. The food is delicous and the atmosphere is fun. The owner makes killer Martinis and the Prime Rib and Halibut is to die for. More

My husband and I have "Thursday Date Night" at Cutten Inn because of the great service and the delicious choice of food and drink. We can go with the idea of having a romantic dinner with just the two of us or with our family and enjoy the company of the family atmosphere that the staff provides. Thursday nights also... More

I always try to visit Cutten Inn when I am in Eureka...It has the feel of a great neighborhood haunt...and you are likely to see a lot of locals that really enjoy the food. I try to make it on Thursday for the Buttermilk Fried Chicken, absolutely the best I've ever tasted. But I also enjoy their Panko Prawns. Be... More

Should have seen it coming by the soup alone. Prawn chowder simply horrible. I tried to eat it but just couldn't. Followed by buttermilk fried chicken which had to be the worst I have ever had. It was bad. It was thick and hard crust that appeared to be fried in shortening. $19.00 for this and I couldn't wait to... More

Good food, good wine, really fun owners and staff! Had a great time. Food was really wonderful! More

I used to drive by The Cutten Inn Restaurant everyday on my way home and did not give a second thought (except the Friday Happy Hour sign) until a colleague recommended it. Cross between a small hometown restaurant but with a warm welcoming atmosphere. Service was prompt and courteous. I the fish, wife the vegetarian, and mother-in-law the steak. Excellent... More

Went to this restaurant based on reviews. Food was good but not as great as the reviews said. Out of ribs so we got prime rib - just okay. No kids menu. Fish and chips were 20 dollars. Good atmosphere. Two extra charges on our credit card? Still working that out. More

We went one night a couple of months ago. I had the fried chicken special, which was just okay, nothing great. He had a steak that we both liked. So when I went back again, I ordered the steak. Told the waitress I'd like it "rare, not raw." "Medium rare?" she asked. Okay, I said, figuring she knew the chef... More