This place is soo cool. The decor is so new england, the food is fabulous. Service is exceptional. It's reasonably priced, easy to get a table, you can sit at the bar, or order take away. Love this place! Shrimp Cocktail is Enormous, and the Boursin Burger melts in your mouth. It's great for cocktails and the cheese plate too.... More

A friend living on Nantucket told us about this place. The food, staff and atmosphere was wonderful. The prices were very reasonable. There were many items on the menu and we had the best hamburgers and club sandwiches! It was dark and cozy with a fireplace as you walk in and there were heavy wooden tables and chairs. We arrived... More

The curly fries, the great selection of beers, wonderful fresh salads, and a congenial crowd; visited at lunch, sat in the outdoor patio - comfortable and relaxed atmosphere. More

... along with the great atmosphere, friendly staff, and good prices made for a lovely memory! More

Interesting ambiance. Behind me was someone swearing like a sailor, to my left was someone bragging about how drunk she'd been the night before, and constantly passing by our table were parents bringing their little ones to the bathroom. A mixed crowd, to be sure. But about the food ... My fiancee said the baked potato soup (a daily special)... More

Were starving and not much choice this time of the year, so were very lucky to end there! My husband is still raving about his dish of mussels! The lobster salads were excellent too. Don't miss it! More

If you looking for the best clam chowder anywhere in the world, stop by the Brotherhood! Chef Christopher Hinds outdid himself with this recipe. I'll assure you will return again and again. More

We've been to Nantucket twice and each time made a point of visiting The Brotherhood. The atmosphere downstairs has to be experienced. Where else will you see a full bar, an elderly couple enjoying an excellent meal, a family with small children and many couples. The food is terrific, and the service (especially our waiter Ivan) is top notch. More

Three distinctly different eating areas; the bar, the dining room upstairs or outside on the patio. All are wonderful locations. The bar area has the most local flavor - both people and decor. Drinks are good, food is wonderful - soups, burgers and sandwiches to full 3 course dinners. Price is right too. More