You can order 1 slice, anyway you like it, which is enough for a meal. Plus a salad and it's perfect. Their California salad rocks. Staff is friendly and really get to know you. Family owned.

I have never had a bad experience eating at or ordering out from New York Pizza Plus. All of their food is great. If you like Italian cannoli's then try them out here! Great overall place.

Having had pizza in New York, and Chicago, no it's not the best of the best. But, unless you are a food snob who only buys a slice in Times Square, or a pie in Little Italy in Chigago, I think you will be pleased here. We sure were. The sauce tasted like sauce, not something from a can. The... More

I was so excited when I finally got around to trying this place. Because of its original name I had thought it was a chain (they have recently changed there name to "O Sole Mio Cucina Italiana"). I have had the New York White pizza on several occasions and it is amazing! (but beware it is very rich). If you... More

Who would have guessed you could get authentic Italian in Alachua? Yep, and it's awesome! New York Pizza Plus an excellent selection and fresh made! They even have pizza by the slice, so you can try some new pizza choices. Rustic and Roma Spinach are very tasty. They have daily chef special that are excellent. That is usually my choice... More

The tiramisu is wonderful ! Great pizza. Daily specials are normally good.

.Original Italian cuisine great . I will suggest everyone to get out of the interstate and enjoy a real authentic Italian dish. Remember it's not just Pizza. You will be surprise the number of dishes in the menu

Last visit was on a busy Friday night, very crowded, we dined outside and there was a nice breeze. We ordered off their Dinner Special menu (Salad, entree & dessert at fixed price) which had at least 15 entrees! I usually am disappointed when a restaurant offers that many entrees, but we were pleasantly surprised. Both our entrees were superb.....the... More

My co-workers and I go here quite often for lunch. They have an amazing salad/pizza bar. There are a ton of choices and for less than $9/pp (with a drink), it's worth it!