Great service, a fantastic dinner and a lovely view from the terrace.
We had a great breakfast at the Sugar Mill. I had apple/pecan french toast, my husband had pancakes both were really delicious! You sit in an open restored sugar mill with a long range view of the ocean. The coffee is self-serve so its nice to get a refill when you want. The service was very good. Next time we... More
Three of us ate here on a summer evening and couldn't have been more pleased. The abeyance was charming and the service warm and friendly, but admitting a little slow, but this type of meal is ideally enjoyed at a slower pace. A bit pricey , but hey its vacation!
I've eaten at Sugar Mill before and the food was better; this time the food was pretty poor for the price. It reminded me of eating in an upmarket provincial restaurant in the UK in 1985 (i.e. not good). Service was slow but friendly. Wine list was good The restaurant itself is picture perfect, a perfect place to engage to... More
It was really good. I got the steak, my fiance got ..something or other, can't remember now...possibly a seafood pasta? We were both very happy with what we got. The servers were nice. We did call ahead and make a reservation, but it was a Sunday night so they weren't terribly busy. It was a little more expensive ($100 for... More
We read reviews and weren't disappointed in the menu, service and atmosphere. Very romantic.
One of the best ways to test the flexibility of a restaurant staff is NOT to call ahead and make a table reservation even if recommended. The head of chef was startled at the moment, checked with others and lead us to a nice table. The two waitresses that served us did so very automaton-like. No smile, no friendly words,... More
There are not many places in Tortola for fine dining, if any. Sugar Mill is as close as you can get on the island. Nice atmosphere, service is good and food is tasty. It has a better feel once is dark as building needs some work. Wine list is also great.
I had a dinner at Sugar Mill for the first time in 14 years. I am enamored by the fabulous serivce; that is a gift. However, I found the food lacking for my expectation from the menu because Sugar Mill is rated as one of the top restaurants on the island. When you are out of an item the staff... More
Ate at "Islands"- their beach side satellite restaurant for lunch. Right on the ocean - perfect for viewing the dozens of pelicans having their lunch. Food was nicely presented, and delicious - only restaurant on tortola I would return to!
If you own or manage The Sugar Mill Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing