𝗧𝗛𝗘 𝟭𝟬 𝗕𝗘𝗦𝗧 Hotels in Sag Harbor, NY
Sag Harbor Hotels
and Places to StayEnter dates to find the best prices
Popular
Property types
Amenities
Distance from
25 km
Traveller rating
Hotel class
Style
Popular hotels in Sag Harbor right now
6 properties in Sag Harbor
Sort by:
- Best ValueProperties ranked using exclusive Tripadvisor data, including traveller ratings, confirmed availability from our partners, prices, booking popularity and location, as well as personal user preferences and recently viewed hotels.
- Traveller RankedHighest rated hotels on Tripadvisor, based on traveller reviews.
- Distance to city centreSee properties located closest to the centre first with confirmed availability for your dates from our partners
Enter dates to see prices
DebraLB
@DebraLB
Reviewed on 2 Jul 2023
i'd stay again
"i had breakfast my last morning in the beautiful dining room and it was delicious."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 6 places to stay in Sag Harbor
Enter dates to see prices
AntonyHurden
@AntonyHurden
Reviewed on 1 Feb 2024
Atmospheric and a delightful way to enjoy Sag Harbor
"As a tourist to the US, we had been staying in Connecticut and decided to have a trip to Long Island and to stay in Sag Harbor. Travelling over by as many ferries as possible (along the North Fork, we passed many..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 6 places to stay in Sag Harbor
Enter dates to see prices
dvorac4
@dvorac4
Reviewed on 19 Nov 2022
Good value for money; very clean; good location
"Excellent location - a block off of the main street on the water (get a harbor view room - it is well worth it) so everything in the small town of SH is very easily accessible via walking yet it is quiet."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 6 places to stay in Sag Harbor
Enter dates to see prices
Ranch
snapkendrapop
@snapkendrapop
Reviewed on 6 Nov 2018
Lovely, affordable spot in the Hamptons
"I attended a writer's workshop at this eco-motel and found this to be a modern and affordable option for a stay in the Hamptons. Of major importance: the entire staff was attentive and warm The room itself was large..."
Read all reviews
#4 Best Value of 6 places to stay in Sag Harbor
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
gogator
@gogator
Reviewed on 15 Aug 2010
roach motel at absurdly inflated Hampton prices
"These cottages are like a 1950s hotel but at an absurd price. There were no beach passes as advertised--well, Monday, but what good was that when there for the weekend? We booked a triple with adult son, got towels..."
Read all reviews
#5 Best Value of 6 places to stay in Sag Harbor
No other properties are available in Sag Harbor. View nearby results below.
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
LAM1971
@1971LAM
Reviewed on 12 Oct 2020
Great Price. Needs more B&B
"We stayed two nights with friends of ours. Beautiful little Victorian House on Shelter Island. Bedrooms decent size. All baths private but across hall from bedrooms. Doors between rooms very thin so can hear a lot..."
Read all reviews
#5 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Shelter Island
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
Kim N
@Kim N
Reviewed on 3 Jul 2018
Lovely setting in the Hamptoms
"We enjoyed staying at the Wainscott Inn for our niece's wedding in Bridgehampton. Rooms were clean, location was convenient, and weekend breakfasts were freshly made. Walk to beach was convenient. Good dining..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Wainscott
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
Maria D
@B5368IVmariad
Reviewed on 16 Jul 2023
Coolest spot in Bridgehampton
"The room was clean and charming."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Bridgehampton
Enter dates to see prices
Inspiration620196
@Inspiration620196
Reviewed on 20 Apr 2022
Stunning Stay at Topping Rose
"We enjoyed w nderful meals, coupled with a spacious, lovely room with a view of the garden from the main house."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Bridgehampton
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Wainscott
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
MsBizWiz2
@MsBizWiz2
Reviewed on 9 Jul 2021
A great restaurant--but no bread....
"This review is for the restaurant, not the hotel:
This restaurant--especially their outdoor garden--would have been perfect but for the chef's dislike of having bread on the menu. (We order corn bread, but it was..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Bridgehampton
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Ashley C
@ashleyelpern
Reviewed on 22 Jul 2019
Excellent location and great accommodations!
"What a lovely place to stay on Shelter Island! My husband and I had a great room at this cozy bed and breakfast. We really were happy to have air conditioning and our own little porch to enjoy the mornings on. The..."
Read all reviews
#6 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Shelter Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
abmullins
@abmullins
Reviewed on 14 Aug 2018
Comfortable Weekday Stay
"My friend and I stayed here during mid-week in August. We arrived late in the evening on the 11pm ferry. The house was very easy to find and our names were left on the door of our room. The decor is a bit dated, but..."
Read all reviews
#7 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Shelter Island
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
#10 Best Value of 11 places to stay in East Hampton
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Yanaabram
@Yanaabram
Reviewed on 25 May 2015
Best of East Hampton
"We stayed at EH colonial over the Memorial Day weekend. The room and patio were clean and spacious, the pool area was very pleasant and Nancy is just a wonderful host. Thank you! Look forward to staying here again!"
Read all reviews
#9 Best Value of 11 places to stay in East Hampton
Enter dates to see prices
Tim from NYC
@TimfromNYC
Reviewed on 8 Sept 2021
Relaxing Summer Getaway with Hardworking Service Team
"I have known Ram's Head Inn (RHI) all my life. I was born and raised across the water in Greenport. Since 2000, my husband and I would celebrate special occasions at Ram's Head including our August 2019 Wedding..."
Read all reviews
#4 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Shelter Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Wendy D
@Wendy D
Reviewed on 7 Jun 2017
Pondview was Perfect!
"My husband and I stayed at the Pondview the first weekend in June and had an incredible experience.
The home and grounds are beautiful and the location is ideal for anyone wanting to experience the Hamptons. We..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Water Mill
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Mark T
@Mark T
Reviewed on 28 May 2017
Memorial Day in the Hamptons spot
"Last year we stayed at The Hermosa Lodge in Watermill/Bridgehampton for a week. Such a great spot with easy access to beaches and all parts of the Hamptons. Nate was the best host at any BnB I've been."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Water Mill
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
kcsch
@kcsch
Reviewed on 3 Nov 2006
Four West Neck Road Bed & Breakfast
"I think the term "Bed & Breakfast" is a bit misguided. This is not a bed and breakfast, it is someone's home and they are charging you to stay. First thing the owners smoke so even though the windows and doors are..."
Read all reviews
#9 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Shelter Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
#3 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Southold
Enter dates to see prices
Small Hotel
KNICKRD
@KNICKRD
Reviewed on 17 Jul 2020
Disappointed, But.....
"I gave it 4 stars only because of the access and use of Shelter Island House.
After our friends booked a room at Shelter Island House for $275, we tried, and it was now $400, we then searched for a more reasonable..."
Read all reviews
#4 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Shelter Island Heights
Enter dates to see prices
Judy M
@JudyM1040
Reviewed on 12 Aug 2021
Shelter Island House
"Our room was large, immaculate w/ a spacious walk-in shower."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Shelter Island
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
Michael M
@S7329MNmichaelm
Reviewed on 11 Jun 2023
A little R&R.
"The room was spacious and bed very comfortable and bedding was supreme."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Shelter Island Heights
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
Marni B
@Passenger599194
Reviewed on 1 Sept 2023
East Hampton Star
"I love the location, and the fact that I can walk to dinner at both of the restaurants. The pool is very nice . My one bedroom cottage was lovely , comfortable, clean , and a great surprise in an area where there..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 3 places to stay in East Hampton
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Angela Houlihan
@Ahoulihan1
Reviewed on 18 Sept 2021
Perfect Setting
"This is a beautiful bed and breakfast in a beautiful setting. Deb and Frank were very welcoming and made us feel at home the entire time!! The room was so comfortable and clean!! Would go back again!!!
Lots to do..."
Read all reviews
#8 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Shelter Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
BATMAN & CATWOMAN
@BATMANCATWOMAN
Reviewed on 9 Mar 2024
An Beautiful Place to Stay
"The Baker House 1650 in East Hampton is just an amazing bed and breakfast experience. It's an old house from 1600's with all the old world charm. If you want to have a massage or the private pool make an appointment..."
Read all reviews
#6 Best Value of 11 places to stay in East Hampton
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
Camper31280158415
@Camper31280158415
Reviewed on 2 Sept 2023
Regular customer turned off
"I have stayed here about 6 times a year for 3 years. The place has been taken over and was hoping for better management. My room -998 a night - was so noisy with noise from the yard and the restaurant. I always book..."
Read all reviews
#8 Best Value of 11 places to stay in East Hampton
Sag Harbor Hotels Information
Hotels in Sag Harbor | 6 |
---|---|
Hotels Prices From | ₹17,893 |
Hotels Reviews | 828 |
Hotels Photos | 429 |
Travel high season | Jun - Aug |
Travel low season | Dec - Feb |
High season avg price | ₹63,931 |
Low season avg price | ₹22,075 |
Not sure when to visit?
Price trends, weather and things to do can help you make a decision.
Season
Avg. price/night
Avg. temperature
Avg. precipitation
Dec - Feb
Avg. price/night
₹27,502
LOWEST
₹15,987₹1,28,065
Avg. temperature
1ºC
COLDEST
-13ºC33ºC
Avg. precipitation
110mm
WETTEST
71 mm133 mm
Mar - May
Avg. price/night
₹28,496
₹15,987₹1,28,065
Avg. temperature
9ºC
-13ºC33ºC
Avg. precipitation
95mm
71 mm133 mm
Jun - Aug
Avg. price/night
₹76,209
HIGHEST
₹15,987₹1,28,065
Avg. temperature
21ºC
WARMEST
-13ºC33ºC
Avg. precipitation
77mm
DRIEST
71 mm133 mm
Sep - Nov
Avg. price/night
₹44,400
₹15,987₹1,28,065
Avg. temperature
13ºC
-13ºC33ºC
Avg. precipitation
104mm
71 mm133 mm
Price trend information excludes taxes and fees and is based on base rates for a nightly stay for 2 adults found in the last 7 days on our site and averaged for commonly viewed hotels in Sag Harbor. Select dates and complete search for nightly totals inclusive of taxes and fees.
Hotels near the sights
- Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the ArtsBay Street Theater & the Sag Harbor Center For The Arts is a year-round, not-for-profit professional theater and community cultural center which endeavors to innovate, educate, and entertain a diverse community through the practice of the performing arts. We serve as a social and cultural gathering place, an educational resource, and a home for a community of artists.Read more
- Foster Memorial BeachRead more
- Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical MuseumA very important maritime museum with items dating back to the 1700s.Read more
- Havens BeachRead more
- Sag Harbor Marine ParkRead more
- Custom House MuseumRead more
- North Haven Village ParkRead more
Frequently Asked Questions about Sag Harbor hotels
- Baron's Cove, The American Hotel, and Sag Harbor Inn are some of the most popular hotels for travellers looking to stay near Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum. See the full list: Hotels near Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum.
- Popular hotels close to Foster Memorial Beach include Baron's Cove, The American Hotel, and Sag Harbor Inn. See the full list: Hotels near Foster Memorial Beach.
- Popular hotels close to New Haven Airport include The Blake Hotel, The Study at Yale, and Graduate New Haven. See the full list: Hotels near New Haven Airport.
- A few of the most popular hotels near Sag Harbor Marine Park are Baron's Cove, The American Hotel, and Sag Harbor Inn. See the full list: Hotels near Sag Harbor Marine Park.