We found the hotel from expedia. We also watched the video from the website... CREEPY!But, we didn't watch it until after we had booked it. We arrived before the check in time so we got to keep our luggage in the lockers, which was convenient. Our room was renovated and very clean. The hotel is definitely in a great location... more

I'm generally a location person when it comes to booking a hotel. You only need a room to sleep and keep your stuff, right? So, I knew I needed a centrally-located hotel/ close to a subway stop on this trip to show my friend around NYC. Herald Square Hotel obviously fits that criteria, but I didn't expect to also get... more

We booked our reservation at the Herald Square Hotel based on reviews here at Tripadvisor and also from the hotel's own website. It seemed like a quaint, historic hotel in mid-town Manhattan, at a very good price. You get what you pay for, my friends. The hotel rooms on the website are charming and well-decorated. The bathrooms look updated and... more

The minute I walked into the lobby, I was greeted with a smiling face. We were given a choice of rooms (how often does that happen?) and were completely satisfied with our decision. The newly renovated room housed a huge bed and a bathroom bigger than some studio apartments I've lived in. The price was right, slightly high because we... more

We stayed at the hotel again, liked it enough the first time to want to come back and we were not disappointed. We stayed in one of the newly renovated rooms, booked it on line 6 weeks before our trip, and it was terrific! A great bed, beautifully appointed bath, clean, quiet and just plain wonderful. I was told that... more

The room was larger than most NYC hotel room (we had 4 gals) and we managed to deal with the tiny bathroom. The room was clean and the maid service was very good. They had coffee, hotchocalate, etc. in a common area on the first floor. I loved the location - convenient to everything. The only problem I really had... more

Stayed this weekend at the Herald Square in a 2 bed unit for 4. Room did NOT look like anything on the web set. Room was very spartan, small with no pictures and stark walls. Old TV and an uncontrollable radiator hissing all night. In the morning, there was no (I mean zero) hot water for showers. Many people complaining... more

We reserved 2 rooms, one with 2 double beds for the kids (teenagers), and another with 1 queen for us. The single room was more updated than the double, but they were both comfortable and clean, the staff was informative and friendly, and I thought the location was great. We would definately recommend the hotel to anyone and we hope... more

We stayed at the Herald Square Hotel for 2 nights. We drove to NY and the hotel has a good deal with a parking lot around the block -parking $21 for 424 hours. Great value for NY. All of our experiences with the staff were good-they were very helpful and polite. The rooms are very clean but ours had only... more