Booked for a night here in mid-October and really enjoyed the stay. Great customer service and very clean. Pool and hot tub were nice as well. Pleasant area in back to walk, play, or just relax. Definitely will be staying again. Thank you!

We have stayed at the Open Hearth Lodge many times over the past 20 years. This fall we went back to the Open Hearth Lodge, after trying a few other places the past few years. I am so glad we went back to Open Hearth Lodge. John and Nora have done a fantastic job updating the entire lodge. The guest... More

We were looking for an overnight stay in Sister Bay when we came across the positive reviews for Open Hearth Lodge and decided to try it. It was all of the things described and then some. I loved the friendliness of the owners and the extra touches, such as the hot cider in the lobby. The room was ave size,... More

This is a quiet town and the Open Heath is very friendly, clean and attractive. The room was big and had plenty of storage space. Hosts were friendly and helpful. One complaint--a family member called from California and asked to ring our room. We were not in and no one took a message to let us know. The desk is... More

We stayed at the Open Hearth Lodge for 2 nights with our son, daughter-in-law, 2 month old grandchild and a dog. The rooms are large and IMMACULATE. The location is good, lovely grounds, nice continental breakfast, pool, whirlpool and friendly staff. We plan to return.

My sister and I went on a girl's weekend to see some lighthouses. We made no reservations. It was around 8:30P when we decided to stop for the evening. This location was advertised in a book we picked up. It appears they have recently remodeled. The room was nicely decorated with a lodge feel and the room was large. It... More

This place has everything going well for it. Big rooms, a pool, and even a backyard with a firepit and patio. The price was right and we enjoyed our stay very much. The only reason I ranked it down 1 point is because we kept getting gruff unfriendly service from the woman who worked the desk. Everything seemed like an... More

Love this place and can't wait to come back and stay again! It has a perfect location in Sister Bay located just a minute or two right down the road, so you don't have to deal with the big city! Looks alot nicer than what the pictures describe it as. Nice pool (that's not cold) and a very nice whirlpool... More

Stayed here in Spring 2012 and it was great. It was a little before tourist season started so not everything was open, but the staff at Open Hearth Lodge knew what was open and suggested amazing places to eat.