This motel is a little older, but very clean. The price is very much in line with other places to stay in Door County. The owners are very friendly and do their best to keep customers happy. The motel is within walking distance to shops, restaurants, and bars. No driving necessary if you want to have a drink with your... More

Rooms are small, dark, and musty-smelling. They have not been remodeled in a long time. Also over-priced. My family and I actually got a great room just up the street at ParkWood Lodge. The rooms were cleaner, cheaper, and they have a pool, hot tub, game room and tennis courts.

Stayed here for a few days. Clean little motel in a great location. Friendly owners. Did I say great location! We'll probably be back, Enough said.

Stayed at the By the Bay over last weekend for an anniversary get away. Rooms are very adequate and SUPER CLEAN!! The staff is very friendly and accomodating. We had a water view room and were just steps away from the beach. Shopping and our favorite restaurants were also within walking distance. It is not a fancy place and the... More

By The Bay Motel is centrally located for everything in Fish Creek. You can walk to either end of town easily and the little beach/park across the street is a plus. We walked to Sunset Beach and Penisula Park in no time. The owners are very friendly and nearby tending to things. My only complaint is that our first night... More

Great location, clean rooms, coffee in the lobby every morning and Mary is wonderful. It is a very economical, right across from the beach and on Main Street, walking distance from all the shops! We have never noticed a musty smell as noted in one of the reviews. I have allergies as well and had no problem with any of... More

This place was a little older, but very clean and nicely decorated. Great location. Just across from the beach and within walking distance to the whole downtown. The walls were very thin,but the place was very quiet. Cleanliness is extremely important to me and this place was immaculate.

We recently stayed in the suite at By the Bay. This was our first trip to Fish Creek and wanted something in the middle of town, and unfortunately we couldn't find much available. I loved the location of this motel (downtown and across from fish Creek beach) but we had to rent the suite at $205 a night and it... More

The rooms are very clean but there are no phones, hair dryers, shampoos, etc. Very old-fashioned in appearance. The air-conditioning struggled to work & our friends who had the room next door did not sleep all night. Their AC sounded like a 747 on take-off! It was awful. When they complained to the woman who owns this establishment she shrugged... More