This was the worst place my husband and I have ever stayed, the pillows on a king size bed are no larger than the throw pillows I have on my sofa, the heater made noises that kept us awake. You couldn't set the heat to a desirable tempature either suffocated or froze. Drip in shower along with hall noise added... More

Frist, I will start by saying that we have stayed in this hotel every September over the past 10+ years. The big tourist attraction is the PA Elk Herd and the area is flooded with people each year over a two-three week period in the fall. This hotel used to be nice, used to be clean, used to be friendly.... More

I was in St. Marys for two nights in June. I spent the first night at the Comfort Inn, per a recommendation from a colleague. It was not a good recommendation. We reserved a room block and the hotel screwed that up (twice). The hotel was in the wrong, but failed to admit their mistake and accommodate our needs per... More

We stayed one night. Didn't have high expectations but the carpet in our room was gross to the touch. Felt like it hadn't been cleaned in years. we literally wore our shoes the entire time and even put them on as soon as we stepped out of the shower. But wait, there's more. Kid you not, there was a huge... More

We were directed to stay at this hotel when we came to this town for a wedding. Although the hotel appears to be quite old, (there was even a beer bottle opener on the wall!), it was a very comfortable and nice stay. The walls appear to be quite thick because we didn't hear any of the commotion that we... More

Stayed in a two double-bed room. Furnishings are old and tired but room was clean. Old CRT tv though they do have wireless internet available. Fitness room has a treadmill, stepper, and bike which worked well. Hot continental breakfast in the AM is nice. I've stayed here a couple of times for work and never had a disastrous experience. Front... More

This property is clean; the rooms are large and well appointed. Special cheers to the staff. They made our stay truly memorable... especially for our charming mini-bull terrier Thomas. More

This is the first time I have ever wrote a review about a hotel and I am making time to write about this one. The hotel is by far the worst hotel I have ever stayed at. You can smell mold in the hallways and rooms. The room was anything but clean. The staff could careless if you have a... More

After touring around some beautiful parts of Pennsylvania and ending up overlooking wild Elk in Benezette. We decided not to drive home but pinged in nearest Hotel on our gps and this Comfort Inn turned out to be only 16 miles away so we went over to it at Saint Mary's. The Hotel would probably get missed if not for... More