Select Registry once again delivered a winner for us with the Settler's Inn. This place is everything an experienced B & B traveler wants. Especially if choosing the BB & D option which includes an elegant formal dinner. As always, inexpensive motel rooms are never hard to find, and sometimes that type of bare bones budget choice is all that's... More

I'm a huge fan of the Arts and Crafts period so of course this inn was perfect for me. Period decor, obviously very well researched, gorgeous Stickley furniture, artwork, tiles, lamps and chandeliers, gorgeous rugs...in all, a very relaxing and beautiful atmosphere. Lovely fireplace downstairs, many comfortable chairs, a dining area, a front porch as well. Our room, 219, wasn't... More

Decided to come here after searching for a place for a one night getaway in the poconos. Came based on 4 diamond rating from AAA and from tripadvisor. The public areas of the hotel are beautifully decorated and the grounds are very nice. Liked the lobby bar For a drink and dessert at night. I stayed in rm 216. Personally... More

After so many amazing meals at Settlers, I felt compelled to write a review! Last night my husband and I went to the Fireside dining and we enjoyed everything from the appetizers to the desserts (not to mention the wine & banana bread beer!!) Settlers is one of the few places my husband and I can go where he does... More

Just returned from a weekend at the Settlers Inn and had a wonderful stay. We did some checking online to find some Inns or Bed and Breakfasts in the area of Lake Wallenpaupack and read the very good reviews that the Settlers recieved so we decided to go there. We were not disapointed! The room,217, was very nice,looked just like... More

My husband and I spent a weekend at the Settler's Inn to celebrate our 20th anniversary. The inn itself is beautiful with a large fireplace in the lobby and bar area. We sat near the fire and enjoyed a few drinks and it was very relaxing. The room was spacious with a fireplace and whilrpool tub. The king size bed... More

Very nice place! we just stayed over one night but it's very nice property. even though we went in Feb. the garden and "Potting Shed" were not open but it was still very nice.

Just returned from 2 nights away at the Settlers Inn and cannot say enough about it! Please note - the pulling up to the beautiful building we were met by mixed reviews as it is located directly off a busy street in a seemingly un-cozy location... but from the moment you walk in you are transported to a different world!... More

I first learned of the inn from reading their profile story in the Spring 2010 PASA (PA Assoc.for Sustainable Agriculture) Newsletter and just always wanted to go for a fabulous dinner and one night getaway. Our dinner on MLK Day was served fireside in the lobby as is the norm on Mondays and Tuesdays.The four course tasting menu with wine... More