I highly recommend this hotel. We arrived fairly late at night with our 16 month old, dreading our 6:15am flight the next morning. The receptionist, Christine, greeted us with such warmth and kindness and was so enthusiastic about our upcoming trip -- that it totally turned things around for us and started our vacation off the right away. She made... More

This is a somewhat odd property, because the exterior and front lobby are completely renovated and fantastic, though once you go past the lobby to the rooms, it quickly becomes quite dreary and worn. So 5-star exterior, 2-star interior. Cons: Our room had some serious electrical/wiring issues. We had to prop our luggage against an outlet to keep the lamp... More

I have read a few of the reviews on here and I must say that I think people expect a $500 night type room when paying less than 75$. The price I received at priceline last minute was very reasonable. When we arrived, we drove up to the door checked in and then proceeded to our rooms. We checked in... More

Had expensive jewelry stolen when I stayed there. There is a thief among the staff as my room was entered and my suitcase opened, my personal items rifled through and the jewelry stolen. The hotel management did nothing but state that the hotel was not liable for valuables left in the room. This is definitely not a safe place. There... More

The double beds in room were too firm, while the pillows were too soft. Antiquated tv with remote that didnt work, limited channels. Bathroom toilet with very low water presssure. Front staff friendly at check in, but not that friendly at check out, not even eye contact was made by representative. Quick response to get remote replaced. Loud groups in... More

I recently spent 1 night at this HI for a wedding. As I was checking in I saw the wedding gift bags for each room labeled & sitting on the floor. We were handed our keys with 10 mins to spare to check-in, change and get 4 miles to the wedding reception. We were given room #545 which we were... More

If you need to fly in and out of Islip, consider this property. We rent a car at the airport and literally drive around the corner to the Holiday Inn! They have an excellent breakfast in the lobby, an open internet kiosk for printing boarding tickets, free wi-fi internet access, and comfortable rooms. More

Good hotel overall, just needs some adjustments to room design... Room window was only covered by a thin curtain, without a thicker curtain or drape for privacy, so was a tad uncomfortable with that, only because my room window was right in the parking lot on the ground floor. Other than that, good value and clean if you have a... More

First of all, I will say LOOK AT ALL THE REVIEWS ON HERE. If it was one or two 'cranks' who didn't get enough soap in their shower saying the hotel management is the worst ever, it would be one thing. But CLEARLY there is a big issue with this hotel's management and staff because SO MANY reviews mention this.... More