Absolutely the worst motel in the east coast, Iwould not let me dog stay here, we had a one night stay in new paltz,, we go there frequently to visit our son who attends Suny NP. we decided to give the rodeway inn a try, we checked in and left right away to go to dinner and visit with my... more

After traveling three hours to get there, we found our room was a smoking room instead of a nonsmoking one. Since my wife and I are asthmatic, we could not use it. The girl at the front desk would not switch us to a nonsmoking room without us paying for an "upgrade", and told us we could phone a manager... more

I had a room in the back part of the hotel...quiet but a little creepy. The sheets had hair on them (not mine); the water was brown and smelled of sulfur. The phone didn't work. The girl at the reception desk was very nice and courteous but the guy who took over in the morning was the complete opposite. more

The room was dirty, air conditioner did not work , window had huge crack and dead bolt did not work. Staff was rude and not at all helpful. Although I reported the problems with the room no repairs were made nor did they transfer me to another room . We had booked three nights but only stayed two as we... more

I was pleasantly surprised by this motel after reading the bad reviews on this site. The motel was in a quiet place, had new comfortable beds, quiet A/C and new bathrooms with granite tops. The morning breakfast was adequate, and the staff was very pleasant. I went to a wedding in New Paltz, and choose this motel because it was... more

We wanted somewhere inexpensive and near to New Paltz and ended up booking the Rodeway without checking Tripadvisor which I now regret. I will say that the girl on reception at night when we booked in was charming and welcoming, so we seemed to avoid the rude people other reviewers have encountered. However, the room smelled very odd, the water... more

I got one of the small suites and was extremely disappointed as it was basically an oversized room with a sofa at one end. The sofa bed did not open and close properly. The security on the building was non-existent since the doors outside of the building, which had card key access, were left open anyway. When I went to... more

I'm in the lobby of the Rodeway Inn writing this review just after checkout. The bed was very comfortable and the room serviceable for $77 a night after tax it wasn't bad. However, the water quality is awful. I think they're on well water and i filled up a cup and it was cloudy! Worst of all, last night the... more

Staff very rude. I was cursed out repeatedly and followed threateningly by desk clerk while with my 10 year old. Asked for a pillow that didn't come in my roomwhich slept 6 but only had 4 pillows.Awful experience and a dirty room too stay away!! more