Room size is good, and it is clean and convenient, but slight dowgrade due to the lumpy, uncomfortable bed. And hopefully you won't have noisy neighbors, the walls (and floor/ceiling) are thin. More

We had a very pleasant visit to Hartman's Briney Breezes this weekend for our first ever trip to Montauk (it certainly will not be our last). I was nervous about traffic since we were leaving the city at 5:30pm on a Friday evening, but Robert assured me that a late arrival would not be a problem. Surprisingly we made it... More

Great place to stay. Rooms are spacious and extremely clean. Nice view and easy access to everything. More

My wife and I go to Montauk in October to fish. The last 4 years we have stayed at Hartmans. My wife refuses to stay anywhere else because everything is so clean. I saw the maid actually clean the windows inside and out and then she proceeded to clean the screens. The grounds are landscaped nicely and the ocean is... More

I didn't end up staying at this hotel due to the rudeness of Robert who I had spoken to a few times regarding a stay on Columbus Day weekend. Originally he offered us very nice accomodations which we were interested in but then took away what he offered when we decided we could not stay the 3 nights (we hadn't... More

Hartman's was as advertised. Yes it is just a motel, and when it is fully booked as it was this past Oct. 1st, it'll get noisy on the balcony. We were in a first floor room and at midnight when the party go'ers got back I had to close the window and turn on the ac, just for the noise,... More

I love Montauk because of the friendly people and ocean beauty. Please don't waste your time in this tacky motel. The owner is a miserable person and the grounds are not kept well. More

Not sure why so many high rated reviews and this hotel has many more reviews than others?? just A motel near the beach. The balconies offer no privacy. Pool opens up a 11:00 AM. More

We stayed at Hartman's Sept 11-15th, 2011. Our upstairs room was immaculate with a very comfortable bed. The kitchen was fully equipped; we were able to cook breakfast in our room and then head to the beach. The beach is across the street, however, it is extremely private and quiet, exactly what we were looking for. After the beach, we... More