This is a reasonably priced place with access to Ithaca fairly easily, which is what we were looking for. We stayed in room 6 which was nice enough. The bed was comfortable and the room was mostly clean. The bathroom had a little night light and they left little candy out for you. Although we didn't really care for their... More

We have eaten at Rogue's Harbor many times, and decided to try an overnight stay for a Valentine's Day getaway. It is the first time I've enjoyed the luxury of being able to walk down for dinner and walk back up to the room, as the B&Bs I have visited before don't have dinner options. It really felt like the... More

Wonderful breakfasts and dinners; big, comfortable and clean rooms; friendly bar with good local selections on tap. Lots of recommendations and information re local attractions (particularly recommend Cornell Plantation and Ithaca Beer Co tasting room). Ithaca is just a short drive away. We will definitely stay here again.

This is a B & B with a restaurant on the ground level. We have not stayed at many B & B's so I did not realize that bathroom facilities are shared, although that was not a problem. The rooms and common areas were nicely furnished; the help was knowledgeable and accommodating. Gravel parking lot on premises. Complimentary breakfast in... More

This hotel is situated at the intersection of two busy roads and the truck traffic is constant. The management changed our room in the hope of allowing us to have a full night's sleep. We stayed in room 5 and 6, however, our sleep was disrupted by the noise. Each room had single pane windows which did not help. On... More

My husband and I truly enjoyed our stay at Rogues Harbor Inn. Our room #9 was very comfortable and beautifully decorated with antiques. The Inn has a fascinating history dating back to the 1830s. There isn't an elevator, so be prepared to walk up 3 flights of stairs to the charming breakfast room. The breakfast was excellent - eggs, potatoes,... More

Stayed 3 nights here over a weekend. Although the property looks a bit "sketchy" from the outside, our room was very comfortable and nicely appointed. All three days our breakfast was quite good, and the staff exceedingly pleasant. Having read previous reviews, I knew there'd be some road noise, but it wasn't a problem - particularly if you have the... More

nicely appointed rooms. Absolutely horrible breakfast. Wouldnt have fed it to a dog. $200 for a room and no attempt to serve a fresh breakfast. Stale bread, pastries. Premade eggs from the day before that were inedible. Told the person in charge. They did nothing and offered no recompense. STAY AWAY!!!!

Our family stayed for a full weekend at Rogues Harbor, booked in three rooms. The experience was fantastic. Rooms were spacious and clean, the breakfasts were great, and the restaurant downstairs was delicious (especially the beer!). Highly recommended.