We were only at the hotel for one night, but that is all it took for us to realize that this was not a place we would be returning. The one night stay was for our friend's wedding. The ceremony was beautiful and it was wonderful to be surrounded by family and friends. It was unfortunate that the wait staff... more

I am writing this review as I still (unfortunately) sit on the bed in my incredibly cramped room. That's because there is nowhere else to sit- this room is tiny and very poorly laid-out. For $180 per night, I got: a broken room lock, a room safe with no lock at all (then what is the point of having a... more

I went to a wedding here and stayed in the hotel. SO CHARMING! First of all, the wedding was amazing with wonderful food and such ambiance with the surroundings of the hotel and the beautiful room. We were so pleased! And the hotel was just wonderful with old charm and amazing service! The food is absolutely unbeatable. I would recommend... more

Go during the week so u can get a room with a balcony, nice views overlooking the pool and navesink river! These rooms are basic, but nice size rooms with King size comfortable beds and balconies. Second floor rooms would have a nicer view but we had a room in the lower lever of the hotel, lots of steps but... more

I arrived very frazzled on the Thursday prior to my son's wedding...an incident with my credit card number being stolen and all the rooms were reserved with that card...the day of preparation and travel had been frenetic. The people who greeted me at 9:30PM saved the day. Throughout the entire weekend I felt the staff and management at The Molly... more

THe hotel is an older hotel so you can't expect everything to be spotless, I understand that but I would never come back. We stayed here to enjoy a weekend getaway and we had previously had brunch at the hotel and the food was nice and the lobby areas looked like this would be a nice hotel. Well, unfortunately, the... more

My wife and I have stayed at the Molly several times when I have been in the Monmouth County area for business, since she grew up in the area over in Middletown. This stay convinced us that we will not be back. The public areas are great and the overall ambiance of this historic hotel is wonderful. The dining room... more

my wife and i stayed there 5/20/2009 well frist i was greeted by the bellhop with a smile and he opened the door for my wife.he then helped me with the bags.we went to the front desk were the woman at the front desk was very pleasend very polite my wife was doing something when i was checking in and... more

We stayed at this hotel for our friends' wedding. The staff was nice. The room was a little cramped but, otherwise, seemed clean and okay for one night's stay for the wedding. The wedding food and service seemed great, and the river/bay view from the hotel back deck was not bad. Overall, I would rate this hotel as a fine... more