This hotel was so clean and friendly. They made sure that we had everything we needed. We had an interior room. Bed was very comfortable and room was quiet, we even had room by elevator and did not hear any traffic or doors slamming. I wanted to stay at Grand Hotel, but stayed her and enjoyed a lunch buffet at... More

We return here yearly. First of all, it's open in October (many island inns are closed for the season by October). Secondly, some of our group members have mobility issues..Main Street has an elevator and is directly across the street from Shepler's Ferry. Thirdly, it is spotlessly clean and service staff courteous and efficient. Fourthly, the beds are so comfy... More

My wife & I brought my parents here for their 50th wedding anniv. Rooms are comfortable, well laid out. we all had one bedroom suites overlooking main street so it was very nice. They have a modern elevator so getting to floors is not a problem. we have stayed at the bed & breakfast inns on the island and they... More

This is really one of a kind hotel. Very clean, nicely furnished. They were very friendly. Good location. Just make sure to get a room to the front. On the backside is a horse stable that can smell pretty bad if you have your window open. The room service is outstanding. We will definitely come back. More

When searching for a proper adjective to describe my recent stay at The Main Street Inn one word just kept coming back to me "nice". Its a common word and hardly seems creative, but it really is the best word for this hotel. This is a new hotel built in 2004 to surround 2 store fronts on Main Street. Because... More

We stayed at the Main Street Inn and Suites the weekend of October 8th for 3 nights. This is the perfect location, right across from the Sheppler ferry and within walking distance to everything on Main Street. The hotel is so beautiful, we stayed in Suite 209 and had a nice balcony with an amazing view of the water and... More

What an absolute gem. We recently spent 2 nights in this hotel and the rave reviews are so accurate. What struck me about Main Street is the cleanliness of the place and the pleasantness of the staff. They certainly do aim to please. Housekeeping was so friendly as well. We had to move to another room the 2nd night because... More

We came here on our honeymoon in September. We stayed in a suite and had an absolutely fantastic time. The staff was so wonderful and thoughtful, the location was great, the room was clean, homey and updated (loved the jacuzzi tub and view!). I could see why this was the most highly recommended hotel on the island and can't wait... More

We rented the two bedroom suite for two nights in the later part of September. Excellent value, and very close to ferry terminal. The decorating was tastefully done in yellows, plaids and blues and the beds vere very comfortable. We had a living room with a tiny balcony overlooking the main street and the harbor. The inn is well cared... More