I'm very late in writing this but wanted to share our experience with the Harbor View. We went to MV in March of this year for a long weekend. I know, I know ... March... as in winter, as in low/off season (i.e. most of the Island is "closed") but we love the Vineyard and wanted to have a quiet... more

We stayed here for one night whilst touring New England and this was the most expensive hotel from the seven we stayed at (one of these was the 5* Boston Intercontinental) The public areas of the hotel are very nice and the exterior is pleasing to the eye. However the same care and attention to detail does not apply to... more

My husband and I have been coming to the Vineyard for years, and have stayed at the Harbor View several times. We had always enjoyed ourselves there before, and decided to book a room there again for our anniversary. We had stayed in the Captain Grafton Collins cottage previously, but this time we stayed in the Governor Mayhew building. BIG... more

My husband and I stayed at this hotel as part of a group business trip. For $385 per night, we were very disappointed. We had Room 15 in the Captain Edmund Bradley Cottage. There was no balcony, 2 small windows, one which provided a lovely view of the dumpsters and the other, which gave us a view of the parking... more

This is our third time staying here and it gets better every time. It is in the ideal location (a 5 minute walk to town...across from the lighthouse...on a quiet street end). The room renevations are great. We stayed in the Meyhew building which was recently re-done. These are the less expensive rooms and they are beautiful and spacious. If... more

At $450 a night we expected top quality in every category. Housekeeping staff is extremely slow and even neglects the standard maintenance of coffee setup in the room (no coffee stirrers, etc). On two consecutive days, we were out of the room for several hours while we were sightseeing; but when we returned, our room had not been cleaned, no... more

My wife summered on the Vineyard from 68 to 72 and for our 35th anniversary I thought it would be nice to revisit the island. The Hotel seemed to be the newest and nicest and the reservationagent who I dealt with assured me that my one bedroom cottage would be great for us at a rate of $380.00 per night.... more

When we booked the Harbor View, we were looking for a premium lodging experience in Martha's Vineyard. We were soooo disapointed. We booked a room in the main building for $425 a night - we figured that would get us a decent room, right? Wrong. We got to the small room to find we had a view of....roof equipment. If... more

Just returned from three night stay with family and really was impressed with the one bedroom suite that we stayed in. Recently renovated, it was the Abraham Morse Guest cottage and it was very spacious and tastefully decorated. Everything is new, including brand new bathroom - it even includes a private outdoor shower which was connected to the bathroom making... more