We stayed at the Edgartown Lodge over Memorial Day weekend. It is located right in the heart of Edgartown, making it walking distance to all of the shops, restaurants, and waterfront. The room was spacious, very clean, and well decorated. This is the place to stay without all of the frills and the high price of other places in town.... More

My girlfriend and I stayed at the Edgartown Lodge in mid-May 2012 for a wedding right down the street at St. Elizabeth Church. It was totally worth it. Just to give context: we are in our late 20s and it was a wedding of a good friend, so we weren't necessarily looking for a quiet weekend. We had people over... More

We stayed at the Edgartown Lodge in July 2012 for a birthday weekend getaway. The hotel is perfectly located as it is in walking distance to the waterfront, shopping and many restaurants. The bus stop is located at a general store/ visitor information center at the end of the street. The room had a quaint, beachy feel. Our room had... More

If you don't need luxury this is the place to stay. Great location and friendly staff. You can walk to everything, the bus stop is next door. Rooms are neat and clean. Make it a point to talk to the staff in stores and restaurants. They are very friendly and give good suggestion about things to do and where to... More

This was our second time staying here, thinking we would have a better experience then before ( thinking it was a fluke and everything deserves a second chance) When we arrived no one was at the office to check in ( same as before), we had to call from a phone outside the office ( which kept disconnecting us from... More

I would stay here again as well. Edgartown is terrific and at a good reasonable price the Etown Lodge puts you right in the center - 200 yds from the bus, walk to the beach, to the shops etc. The room is very clean and simple, the owner very nice with lots of good advice on restuarants, places to go,... More

I would definitely stay here again! It's in a great location right by the bus stop and many restaurants in Edgartown. The manager and owner were extremely friendly and helpful. I'd highly recommend this place.

Edgartown Lodge was a wonderful place to stay. They had a refrigerator and microwave which was very helpful in a very expensive town. Convenient and close to downtown Edgartown.

My family was visiting some friends on teh island and they had room for some but not all of us. So we rented a room at the Lodge based upon price and it was more than we expected. The room was clean, tyeh mattress was good and the bathroom was immaculate. There was none of the typical musty beach hotel... More