Beautiful hotel, in perfect location a few blocks off Duval. Lovely colonial style rooms, nice breakfast ( pity they're stopping this soon), amazing gardens, helpful staff. Nice pool. Can't fault it. Don't even THINK of booking somewhere else.

Stayed for four nights during a recent dive vacation. The property is very convenient to the old wharf or Key West Bight. I had room #22 on the third floor of the main building. It was pretty large with a full kitchen and a nice bathroom. The furnishings were nothing special, but adequate for one or two people. The porch... More

It was super nice to stay at this hotel. Our suite was excellent, staff was really helpful and friendly, the garden is beautiful and the pool is good as well. But the best was our porch with the view of the garden. Excellent!!

We stayed at Island City House in the Arch House room 4 a Queen suite with a garden view and a private balcony March 31 - April 5 .The room was perfect. The cleaning staff kept it very clean and we always had clean fresh towels.The sign said no vacancy but we never saw or heard anyone. Its location is... More

This is a damn nice hotel, quite and off the main path. Nice room with an overlook in the garden. Bed and shower were clean and the staff were damn nice as well. Pool was junk, small. If you have children, they might like it but overall junk. The breakfast was a nice wake up. Nothing to blow your hair... More

I stayed at the Island City House last week. It was a great experience. They had our room ready even though our plane arrived early in the day. Staff was helpful and very nice. The grounds are absolutely beautiful as well. We stayed in the Arch house on the second floor facing Eaton street. The room was lovely and the... More

I have stayed at the Island City House on two occasions. I can't wait to go back! I felt so at home there. The gardens are lovely, the rooms are charming, they even come with a cat if you choose to let one in to visit! The pool was a great place to be to escape the heat of the... More

The Island Cuty Hotel is located in a spot that allows you the ability to walk anywhere around Duvall St. The room was inspiring! Breakfast amongst the orchids and other tropical flowers was such a treat every morning. The staff was helpful and extremely polite. For me, the frosting on the cake was having one of the resident cats stroll... More

Just got back from a 5 night stay at Island City House Hotel and Key West. Really liked this place. The buildings and grounds were very cute and quaint, lush tropical plantings, roaming kitties, all verandas and awnings and shutters. Felt very old-style, tropical plantation, and very romantic. We stayed in the Island City House itself, which fronted onto William... More