We stayed here for one night before going to another hotel in Key West and wished we had remained for our entire stay. Such beautiful accommodations in a tranquil garden setting. The rooms really give you a taste of historic Key West the way Hemingway would have known it. We will stay here whenever we are lucky enough to get... more

My New Husband and I stayed here for 4 days in October for our honeymoon and we loved every minute of it. The rooms were clean, cozy but spacious and very comforting. We has a full sized kitchen and queen bed. It was very quite and still within walking distance of Duval and mallory square. The gardens were beautiful and... more

We stayed at the Island City House the first full week in October. This was our second trip to Key West and this is definitely the best time to visit, in my opinion. It is not busy this time of year! We stayed in the Cigar House again. The grounds are beautiul and the staff is very helpful and friendly.... more

Island City House Hotel was absolutely lovely. The rooms were large, clean, very well-appointed, and very tastefully decorated. There was a fairly large variety of foods served at the continental breakfast. My husband and I were travelling with our toddler: he was welcomed by all and greatly enjoyed the small pool. The garden courtyard is blissful. Really enjoyed that it... more

My partner and I recently stayed at the Island City House in Key West. I did not know anything about the hotel or location. I went completely by their website and advice here on Tripadvisor.com. And i loved the Island City House!!! First off, the hotel's grounds are green and very tropical. There is a winding brick path that snakes... more

This was our first bed and breakfast we stayed at. The rooms are very large and clean, and there is a beautiful courtyard where breakfast is served. I thought the cats on property were cute, they love kitty treats!! The hotel is within walking distance of just about everything in Key West, although you might want to consider a bike... more

Beautiful grounds, nice clean rooms, and walking distance to just about everywhere. My husband and I shared a 2 bedroom suite with another couple. We took advantage of a special they offered for April - stay 2 nights, 3rd night free. Great value for what we were looking for. We didn't need an on site restaurant, a business center, any... more

Island City House is the perfect place if you want a small apartment instead of the common room that really only gives you a place to sleep. We stayed in the Carriage House facing Eaton St. on the second floor. The room had a large bathroom, nice kitchenette and the bed was tucked away in an alcove. Staying here was... more

We have stayed at various places on Key West for a few years now and were driven out of our previous fave by increased prices. We decided to give ICH a try based on the good reviews online and by the relatively reasonable prices and we were not disappointed. Our queen suite was lovely, if decorated in a manner (Victorian)... more