We got married on Anna Maria Island (The Sandbar, also highly recommended!) and had beach houses rented for our wedding party and family, but we had all of our guests (~40-50ppl) stay at the Tortuga Inn, and we got great reviews from all of our guests who stayed on property. We also stayed here the night of our wedding in... More

We returned to the Tortuga for the 5th or 6th time, I admit I was a little concerned with some of the negative comments made on this site and the changes that had been made. However, our welcome in reception was excellent, our room was fantastic (not sure why people say the rooms are dark, they are shaded - keeps... More

We stayed at the Tortuga for 3 nights while attending a wedding and were very impressed from the start. Front desk staff were friendly and while they could not accommodate an early check-in, the room was well worth the wait. It was beyond our expectations! The room was absolutely beautiful! We wished we could have stayed longer. Beach was directly... More

We needed a room foe just one night on Mother's Day weekend....luckily we found the Tortuga abd they had an amazing 2br/2bath. Granite, crown molding dual head showers in both baths....if we would have known what a great place it was we would have definitely planned a longer stay. Our room shared a private pool with a few other rooms.... More

Late planning and a bit of luck turned into one of the loveliest places we have ever stayed! Visited Anna Maria Island over Easter weekend and it was absolutely the best! Tortuga Inn is nicely situated approximately center of the Island and was bright, clean, spacious and an extremely pleasant experience. The beach is gorgeous and right at your fingertips.... More

This place is the real deal. If you do your homework, Anna Maria Island is a quiet, laid back, non-party location that is ideal for a quiet getaway where you just want to relax, eat good food and enjoy an amazing beach. And this hotel makes that experience perfect! The front desk staff are the nicest, fun folk. The Gulf... More

First of all, I love the website, which was why I chose this hotel in the first place. The Inn has excellent pictures of the rooms, and of the resort-and the pictures do not exaggerate! The rooms, pool and beach are lovely and spacious. Also, the staff at the front desk is very friendly and helpful. We felt very much... More

We visited our favorite Florida beach again this year for another family vacation. We absolutely love Anna Maria Island but just hate that the word is getting out! This year we went during Easter week which I had heard would be 100X busier and more costly than October, well it was BUT not THAT bad! Stayed a week and stayed... More

As Anna Marie Island fans this was a no brainer. We stayed in July last year and are going back again in Sept this year. Clean, friendly, perfect location. The rooms are delightful and have all you need for a relaxed few days. Get up early, wander over onto the private beach and you can be the only person in... More