First off if you want a perfect place look elsewhere. If you’re looking for a good place with everything within walking distance, this is the place! Ten years ago, the management had all but ruined the hotel, but the last ten years, with good management, have been positive ones for the hotel and hopefully things will continue. The hotel staff,... more

We traveld with a group of 11 for a wedding. There was a child age 8 in the group. The wedding was picture perfect. We enjoyed everthing about this private island. The rooms need some work with A/C and Plumbing (nothing major) but they were cozy and clean. All rooms have a nice size kitchenette with micorwave, small fridge, sink,... more

My husband and I got married here in June 2000. It was a beautiful wedding on the beach at sunset under the palm trees, truly storybook. Then my son got married in July of 2007 and we returned here for a visit. It truly is quaint, quiet, calming and very islandy. You have to take a small boat to get... more

Sure the hotel needs some updating but the location is awesome!!! It was HOT in our room when we checked in and it took all afternoon to cool down. But after the first day it was fine. The water never got hot, just warm, but once you got used to it that was fine. The restaurant and bar was closed... more

Great view of Fort Christiansted from the cay in the harbour! The quick 3 minute ride on the hotel provided launch back and forth to the dock makes the stay and the seclution all that more enjoyable! The staff and the tours were all fantastic! Thursday night is BBQ night at the bar on the beach. The show and the... more

Yes, the Hotel on the Cay DOES need updating, is not 5-star perfection & you can't play on the tennis courts...BUT you can walk into the water from the tennis courts & see stingray, puffers, mantas, octupus & all sorts of marine life. You can enjoy a 360 view of Christiansted Harbor from the upper part of the HotC property,... more

Just got home from a great trip to St. Croix. I have been to all three US virgin islands and love St. Croix the best . Very laid back atmosphere and not busy like the other islands. We found Hotel on the Cay perfect for our needs , the price is the best in the area and it is the... more

The hotel is older and could use some updating. The first room I was in was not acceptable and we moved to a different room and we were happy. The location of the hotel is fantastic. We will go back again. more

We spent a week here and loved every minute of it! The staff is very friendly and helpful but especially the boat captains! We enjoyed the hotel beach and if you have little ones, this beach is perfect for you. No waves, lots of little fish swimming about, soft sand, and we never had more than 10 people on it... more