We read some of the reviews just before leaving and I said to my husband that I didn't even want to go. Others we met there felt the same way. We were all very pleasantly surprised! The property is older and very well maintained. Our 1BR suite was lovely. It had been recently redone and was spacious and spotlessly clean.... more

We arrived at Oyster Bay with the idea that we were not going to be overly critical or have expectations that were unreasonable. The front desk staff and in fact the entire staff were very courteous and helpful. We've been all over the Caribbean and were pleasantly surprised at the clean accomodations. We enjoyed the quiet location of OBBR along... more

We are timeshare owners here. We bought in the late nineties before the new section was complete. Unfortunately, we are still looking at the same furniture that was new ten years ago. The hideaway bed has had one too many nights spent on it. This facility is looking tired. The rooms are clean and equipped with everything required for a... more

We have stayed here twice on a time share exchange. The place is showing its age and the new "Lighthouse" structure is one of the ugliest buildings on the island but we like the location because it is away from the noise, congestion, casinos, and shopping areas. In contrast to some of the reviews, we found the staff very polite... more

My husband and I went for a week to celebrate our one year anniversary. Upon arriving to OBBR, we were waiting in line to check in and a hotel staff person came over and asked for our names. He went behind the desk, got our information and brought us to our room. This was great and we didn't have to... more

Just got back, here's a recap of our impressions: - Generally: if you go expecting some dazzling Waldorf Astoria type place, you'll probably come back ranting and whining. Go in with modest expectations (which we did after reading these reviews) and you should be fine, at least we were. - We had an efficiency on the bayside (marina). It was... more

My husband and I were actually taken aback by the indifferent attitude of the hotel and desk staff. They were an immediate "NO" to virtually all of our requests. We are frequent travelers and easy going people so we were constantly amazed at the negativity we experienced. Additionally the place is in grave disrepair, chipped paint, stained walkways and steps.... more

My wife and I stayed at OBBR for a week, swapping a Marriott week in order to be with friends who have a timeshare at OBBR. Even though I swapped a one-bedroom unit, and even though it was really low-season (about 25% occupancy at the resort) we were placed in an efficiency (#3910) that looked over the street ,through the... more

Oyster Bay Beach Resort is one of my favorites. Everything is always clean and activities are always going on. The rooms can use an update, as per management that will be happening soon. The staff is friendly and very accomodating. more