We loved this place from the minute we got off the boat! The Rum Punch is the best on the island. Be careful though, it catches up to you fast! Get ready for some fun with Eudoxie! His salty language adds additional color to the experience. He sure knows how to cook up some crayfish! The freshness and quality of... More

Great place. Plan on spending the whole, food is great, the owners are great.The island is small, which is good.Have been there many times. BUD CARTER

Scilly Cay is on the northern part of the island and is a "must do." Make a reservation at 264-235-5000 for around 1pm and plan to stay for the rest of the day. To get to Scilly Cay, drive to the East End and follow the signs to Island Harbour. Park in the center of town alongside the road where... More

Scilly Cay is SO pretty ! Arrive by boat - enjoy rum punch while your chicken or lobster is grilling..and take a swim in the turquoise water and enjoy the pretty little beach before relaxing under your shady parasol that covers your table in the sand. Friendly service, relaxed ambience . Watch the little hermit crabs as they scamper between... More

This place is terrific. There are only a few choices for meals, crayfish, lobster or chicken but wow. It's as good as it gets. The location is a small cay, about 250 feet in diameter which you need to take a boat ride to. I was reluctant because I prefer to choose when to leave rather than wait for transportation.... More

Ever wanted to hang out on a unbelievably beautiful private island with a few great friends and eat amazing seafood? If your answer was yes, this is your place. I've seen some people complaining about the price, but lets face it, they are fools. The food alone is basically worth the price, but then on top of that you get... More

This is an island restaurant that is onlyreahced by a free motor launch from Harbour Island. Specialty is locally caught crustaceans. Food is not cheap, but it's an OK experience. Briing cash, as last I was there no credit cards were accepted.

At Scilly Cay you leave your troubles behind. The excellent food and rum punch are a welcome treat. The pace makes you slow down which is what you came to Anguilla to do. We enjoyed the beautiful surroundings, marveled at the native boats floating in the harbor, and let the warm tropical breeze wash over us. We have traveled to... More

Go to the docks, buy fresh fish (snapper, crayfish) and try your hand at grilling it yourself. Make sure to spend time talking to the locals hanging out at the pier.